Dr. Jacob Agronin, a physician at Temple University Hospital in Philadelphia, has received an exemption from union membership and associated fees. This decision followed his challenge against a requirement to support a union financially, which he said conflicted with his religious beliefs.
America First Legal (AFL) intervened in this case, addressing the Committee of Interns and Residents (CIR), Service Employees International Union (SEIU) Local 1957. They argued that the union’s positions on Israel, including support for the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement, contradicted Dr. Agronin’s religious convictions.
The union’s collective bargaining agreement with Temple University Hospital required employees to join the union or pay agency fees, according to AFL.
Attorney Megan Redshaw from AFL clarified that while Dr. Agronin did not object to the union’s freedom of political speech, he believed that any financial support would infringe upon his religious beliefs, even if it did not fund political actions directly. Ultimately, the union confirmed in a letter dated October 9 that Agronin was neither a member nor paying dues.
“No fees will be deducted from his paycheck,” noted Redshaw, emphasizing that Agronin’s request was grounded in Jewish law. CIR represents over 40,000 resident physicians and promotes improved training, patient care, and healthcare access.
In May 2024, CIR passed resolutions concerning Israel, including “Housestaff for Human Rights” and “Housestaff Against Apartheid,” indicating a stance against candidates supported by the Israel lobby and calling for ceasing military aid to Israel. They also endorsed the BDS movement.
After the October 7, 2023, attacks by Hamas on Israel, CIR expressed shock at the ongoing violence, mourning the lives lost. They called on U.S. leaders to restore essential services in Gaza and advocated for the release of hostages.
Dr. Agronin, in testimony to Congress in May 2026, acknowledged the aspects of mourning both Israeli and Palestinian casualties but contested the statement’s neutrality. He highlighted the omission of Hamas’s mention and criticized the seemingly balanced portrayal of perpetrators and victims in the conflict.
Redshaw also mentioned that physicians with similar religious concerns might obtain complete exemptions from union fees and membership. Many people mistakenly believe that religious accommodations only allow for partial fee exemptions, often redirecting funds to union-chosen charities.
Neither CIR nor Temple University Hospital provided immediate responses to Fox News Digital’s requests for comments.
Rachel Wolf contributes as a media and culture reporter for Fox News Digital.
