Sophie Cunningham, a player with Indiana Fever, has stirred significant controversy following her defense of women’s sports. A column in The Athletic, owned by the New York Times, suggested that Indiana Fever should part ways with her. The article argued that Cunningham’s outspoken views have overshadowed the team’s focus on basketball.
Fox News contributor Kat Timpf and podcast host Kennedy discussed this issue with Ainsley Earhardt, noting that a large portion of the country backs Cunningham’s stance. They previewed a new episode of the ‘the Girls’ podcast, where this topic is likely to be further discussed.
In response to the criticism, Cunningham bluntly replied with “Suck it” to the idea of her being dropped from the team. She explained during an episode of “No Hesitation with Sophie Cunningham & Drew Hanlen” that outside opinions no longer influence her life choices. She emphasized, “If you’re going to live by the praise, you’re going to die by the hate.”
The Athletic’s column described Cunningham as “too combustible” and claimed her presence disrupts basketball priorities. Moving toward unrestricted free agency after two seasons with Indiana, her public stance on transgender athletes competing in women’s sports sparked protests both supporting and opposing her viewpoint outside Fever games. Despite the demonstrations, Cunningham was unbothered by potential distractions for her team.
Her co-host, Drew Hanlen, criticized the column labeling it an “absolute hate piece” but chose to address the basketball-related points. He defended Cunningham’s basketball reputation, highlighting her ranking as the fourth among bench scorers and a top-five three-point shooter in the WNBA.
Hanlen challenged the column for undervaluing her effectiveness, citing her 60.8% effective field goal percentage, which ranked fourth in the league. Emphasizing basketball facts, Hanlen remarked, “Don’t try to put down the basketball stuff.”
During the regular season, Cunningham averaged 7.9 points, 2.3 rebounds, and 1.2 assists across 43 appearances, with a 41.9% success rate from three-point range. Although the column recognized her as a valuable team player, it argued that her contributions sometimes extend beyond conventional statistics.
Regardless, Cunningham remains assertive about her abilities and commitment to Indiana Fever. She stated, “No matter what anyone says, I’m going to continue to do me. I know what I bring to the table. It’s not always in the stat sheet.”
