“Nobody wants to talk to you. I’m trying to be nice.” These were the words from a Camas High assistant cross country coach at the Nike Hole in the Wall High School XC Invitational in Arlington, Washington. The coach’s words came as I stood near the Women’s Elite 5k race start line.
At the center of the tension was a Camas runner participating in the Women’s Elite 5K, who is a biological male. This runner switched from the boys’ team to the girls’ team midseason. Initially, he ran with the boys, placing 76th in a JV race. However, after joining the girls’ team, he took first place in a varsity meet and second in another invitational.
This switch has brought national attention and left Camas on the defensive. Many people, particularly parents from opposing schools, expressed their opinions. Kent Lake of Lake Stevens, WA, said, “We’re about as liberal as it gets. I just don’t agree with that [boys competing against girls]. It’s like stock car racing. It’s got to be even, and it’s got to be fair.”
The reason for the Camas runner’s team switch remains unclear. Coaches and the boy’s mother were reluctant to discuss the situation. Although such a switch is allowed under the rules of the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association (WIAA), many parents disapprove.
One anonymous parent said, “When I first heard about this story, I was like, ‘Is this real? That can’t be real.’ We have daughters, and it’s robbing them of an opportunity to compete.” Concerns revolve around the potential impact on female athletes’ opportunities.
Despite finishing 39th out of 135 in the girls’ race, the male runner’s participation remained controversial. “Whether they finish first, 40th, or 90th, they’re still taking the spot of a girl,” remarked another parent.
Opinions at the event varied. Some parents emphasized building confidence over winning. One stated, “People can identify however they want. High school sports isn’t about winning.” Another commented on the need for empathy and compassion but acknowledged potential complications from midseason team changes.
Kevin Ess, an Arlington High parent, expressed a mixed view: “Men and women, young men and young women, have been competing separately for hundreds, thousands of years. It’s an interesting experiment and topic, but they should continue to compete separately.”
Some participants, like Skyview High runners Charlie Garrett and Sierra Retzlaff, protested by walking off the start line. Retzlaff explained, “Because if we don’t, no one else will. If we start something, maybe others will have the courage to join.”
This ongoing debate has spurred actions like Initiative 638, which aims to ban biological males from competing against girls in K-12 sports, appearing on the Nov. 3 ballot in Washington state. A mother urged, “There needs to be more work done to change the law… People need to get out and vote for what they want.”
Matt Calkins is a columnist at Outkick, focusing on sports and culture intersections. Previously, he was a sports columnist for the Seattle Times. Follow him on X at matt_calkins.
