October 30, 2026

Colorado Mother Raises Concerns Over Preschool Program’s Religious Exclusions

A Colorado mother claims her family was denied $12,000 in preschool benefits due to opting for a Catholic education, alleging state discrimination against religious families. Erika Nagle’s children attend St. Mary Catholic School in Littleton. She reported to Fox News Digital that two of her children couldn’t access the state’s preschool funding program, forcing her family to bear extra educational costs.

Nagle stated, “We are being excluded from this benefit because we are Catholic,” emphasizing that despite the state’s focus on inclusion, religious families face exclusion because of their beliefs.

Legal Dispute Centers on Colorado’s Universal Preschool Program

The Supreme Court will address the challenge from Catholic entities after Colorado restricted their participation.

The controversy surrounds Colorado’s universal preschool program, which Nagle claims provides over $6,000 per eligible child. Catholic schools are contesting the program, arguing that it imposes unfair conditions on their religious beliefs and admission practices.

According to Becket, Colorado introduced its preschool funding initiative in 2023, granting eligible families around $6,300 for 15 hours of weekly preschool. The program purportedly allows parents to choose between public, private, and religious preschools, leading Catholic families statewide to seek involvement.

Nagle said the impact extends beyond financial strain. “We have had two preschools in the archdiocese that have been closed down,” she mentioned, noting the program’s detrimental effect on Catholic school enrollment and the pressure to abandon desired religious education.

Admissions Criteria and Religious Schools

Nagle contended that nearly every school has admission criteria aimed at its community, be it neighborhood children, LGBTQ individuals, special needs children, or low-income families. She explained St. Mary’s priority for Catholic families while welcoming students of all backgrounds who respect the school’s teachings.

Nagle queried the differential treatment of Catholic school’s admission methods. “The state provides $6000 per family for the year before kindergarten, to be used at any preferred school,” she explained. “Catholics face higher costs for choosing Catholic schools compared to other families.”

This situation prompts debates about religious schools’ participation in publicly funded education programs and their admission policies.

Concerns Over State Exemptions

Nagle asserted, “Colorado shouldn’t force Catholic families to forfeit their choice, a faith-based school, while other schools serve their communities.” She questioned whether the state’s actions aim to pave a path toward secularism, asking why exemptions are granted to some schools but not to Catholic institutions.

The Supreme Court will review the case on Tuesday. Meanwhile, a spokesperson from the Colorado Department of Early Childhood (CDEC) stated that the department wouldn’t comment on ongoing litigation, and Colorado’s Governor’s office hasn’t provided a response yet.

TAGS: