Trump Administration Requests Judge’s Recusal in Tree-Cutting Case
The Trump administration has asked for the recusal of U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes in a legal dispute over tree removal at East Potomac Golf Links in Washington, D.C. The Justice Department claims that Reyes showed bias during hearings and mishandled government lawyers.
Accusations Against Judge Reyes
The Justice Department argues Reyes belittled and shouted at government attorneys during an October 12 hearing in the case involving the historic golf course. The administration accuses Reyes of questioning the competence of government lawyers and influencing case proceedings with her opinions against the Trump administration.
“Judge Reyes’s behavior in this case is nothing short of egregious,” the administration stated.
The DOJ highlighted Reyes’s remark to government counsel indicating their intelligence might be insufficient: “If you don’t understand the relevance of the questions we’re asking, the government has a much bigger problem than I understood it to have.”
Reactions and Background
Democracy Forward Foundation, representing the plaintiffs in the case, had no additional comment on the filing. A spokesperson for the Department of the Interior referred inquiries to the Justice Department.
The lawsuit, filed by the D.C. Preservation League and two residents, opposes removing Reyes from the case, stating no grounds for her disqualification or recusal.
Judicial Misconduct Claims
The Justice Department accuses Reyes of showing a pattern of animosity toward the Trump administration, referencing other litigation cases to support its claim. Reyes was appointed by President Joe Biden and began her tenure in 2023.
Her previous conduct, including another judicial misconduct complaint linked to Trump’s military policy, is cited in the DOJ’s motion for recusal.
Tree-Removal Operation at East Potomac Golf Links
Judge Reyes disputed the government’s credibility after the removal of approximately 430 healthy trees at the golf course without prior notice. The tree removal operation is part of a broader legal dispute over the redesign of East Potomac Golf Links.
Reyes criticized the expedited tree-cutting process, asserting that it lacked necessary environmental review and budget clarity.
“Breakneck speed to clear trees that posed no harm. The reason? Disputed. The budget? Unclear. The environmental impact? Unstudied. The urgency? None.”
The administration insists the tree cutting is rooted in a 2019 landscape plan, unrelated to Trump’s course redesign.
DOJ Challenges Judge Reyes’s Authority
The Justice Department objects to Reyes’s decision demanding testimony from high-ranking officials without adequate justification. Reyes has requested Gregory Wischer and Jessica Bowron to testify about the authorization of the tree-removal operation, a move the DOJ considers a breach of separation-of-powers principles.
The situation represents an escalation in courtroom disputes, with the DOJ accusing Reyes of overt hostility and acknowledging her ability to oversee the case is compromised.
