In 1848, Horace Mann, a notable education reformer, described public schooling as “the great equalizer of the conditions of men.” Over 175 years later, the debate about whether his assertion holds true continues among education scholars. Research offers varying perspectives. Some studies argue that a child’s family background has a more significant impact on their academic performance than schools do. Others suggest schools help narrow gaps in academic achievement, preventing them from widening.
A notable study from the 1980s involving Baltimore children showed that low-income and wealthier kids had similar learning rates during the academic year. However, over summer breaks, achievement gaps expanded. Some children enjoyed activities like reading with parents, visiting libraries, and attending camps, while others missed such opportunities. The extent of summer learning loss is uncertain, yet gaps in reading and math skills between rich and poor are prominent from the first day of kindergarten largely due to factors beyond K-12 education. For many students, these gaps remain stable throughout their school years.
I study education policy, focusing on factors affecting student learning, including teacher quality. Typically, research measures student learning within schools. Instead, my colleagues and I recently assessed the resources students receive both in and outside school, such as funding, education support services, and family contributions.
Gaps from Early Childhood
In a 2026 study, we used data from 10 representative government surveys to track 77 types of investments, including teachers, tutoring, housing, food, and childcare, that contribute to child development. We also valued non-monetary factors like time spent by parents reading with children. These were quantified using the average U.S. hourly wage to compare investments across different demographics.
On average, children in the U.S. receive approximately $502,000 in resources from birth until age 18. Significant investment gaps appear early; before turning 5, children from the lowest income families receive about $44,000 less than their wealthy counterparts, marking a 24% gap. This difference mainly stems from disparities in housing and childcare expenditures.
Entering Elementary School
As children enter elementary school, the investment gap notably narrows. The difference between the richest and poorest children reduces from 24% to 12%. Black children experience an even sharper decline, with their investment gap shrinking from 20% to 7% once they begin kindergarten. Research indicates that increased school funding can improve student outcomes, particularly for low-income families.
Challenges in Closing Achievement Gaps
Despite increased funding, achievement gaps persist through school years. One explanation involves what the money is spent on. Our research shows that children from low-income families receive significantly more tutoring and special education services compared to wealthier peers. These services aim to help students catch up. However, a dollar spent catching up isn’t equivalent to a dollar spent advancing academically.
Tutoring has long been used as a tool to help lagging students. Schools have increased reliance on it, especially post-pandemic. Evidence from studies assigning tutoring randomly to students has shown significant test score improvements. Schools serving many low-income students have utilized federal Title I funds for tutoring. The influx of pandemic relief funds has bolstered these efforts further.
Federal Support and Its Impact
Congress allocated nearly $190 billion to schools, dividing resources similarly to Title I allocations, thereby aiding high-poverty districts. By 2022-23, over a third of schools offered “high-dosage” tutoring. Schools with more low-income and minority students were likelier to offer these services. However, for many low-income, Black, and Latino children, tutoring is not novel. According to our data from 2014 to 2021, approximately 17% of school-aged children received tutoring, including 25% of Black and 19% of Latino children, compared to 14% of white children.
Early pandemic recovery showed little increase in tutoring prevalence, with surveys indicating about 15% of students receiving such support. Nonetheless, the pandemic widened achievement gaps. Students in high-poverty districts remain behind wealthier districts compared to pre-pandemic norms.
Going Beyond Catch-Up Strategies
While catch-up efforts address existing gaps, additional resources used by wealthier families further widen disparities. Low-income students and students of color more often have less experienced teachers than wealthier, white peers. This pattern is evident not only in school but also in extracurricular activities. Wealthier families significantly outspend others on music, sports, and other enrichment activities.
Our findings reveal that public education helps reduce investment gaps among children from diverse economic backgrounds. Equal spending doesn’t equate to equal opportunity, as much of the extra school spending targets pre-existing gaps. Meanwhile, wealthier children benefit from continued access to experienced teachers and enrichment activities.
Achieving true educational equity requires more than just catch-up strategies. Low-income students need access to resources that advance their learning, similar to their wealthier peers. With the widest gaps forming before kindergarten in areas like housing and childcare, addressing them should not rest on schools alone.
David Blazar, Malen Professor for Urban Education Policy, University of Maryland
This content is sourced from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license and is based on an original article found here.