October 16, 2026

The Impact of Debates in Midterm Elections

The midterm debate season is underway, providing candidates an opportunity to confront rivals and present their cases to voters as Election Day approaches. The central question remains: Do debates influence the outcomes in competitive races?

This week, Senate candidates clashed in key states like Maine, Iowa, and Georgia. However, key Senate races in Texas and Ohio, as well as gubernatorial races in Nevada and Ohio, have yet to feature debates. Despite concerns over TV debate viewership and the potential for errors on stage, experts argue that debates can still be pivotal. A standout performance or a major misstep could be decisive for candidates. Notably, a poor debate showing affected Joe Biden’s 2024 reelection trajectory.

Several debate performances have influenced critical campaigns, from John F. Kennedy’s televised debate against Richard Nixon in 1960 to Marco Rubio’s face-off with Chris Christie in 2016. However, the link between debate reactions and voting outcomes remains murky. The question of their importance resurfaces as some candidates choose to skip debates.

For instance, former Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms participated in a debate with Republican Rick Jackson, who declined a subsequent event. Similarly, Nevada’s Attorney General Aaron Ford faced an empty podium as his opponent, Governor Joe Lombardo, did not join the debate. Discussions continue as viewers wonder whether presenting oneself in a debate is essential to the democratic process.

Debates provide a platform for candidates to capture voter attention, beyond just for the live audience but also through social media shares. As Aaron Kall, director of debate at the University of Michigan, notes, the dream is to produce moments that resonate and spread on platforms like Instagram and TikTok.

This cycle, Republicans have used debates to distance themselves from presidential policies, especially concerning sagging approval ratings and economic discontent. Ashley Hinson, Iowa’s Senate GOP candidate, expressed opposition to recent deals with Russia over fuel prices during a debate. Former Rep. Mike Rogers of Michigan highlighted calls to Canada’s Commerce Secretary to discuss tariffs.

Debates also bring risks, illustrated by Senator Darline Graham’s misstep during a South Carolina Senate runoff debate. She admitted her unfamiliarity with national security topics, which her opponent, Annie Andrews, later criticized.

Kall states debates still influence close races, particularly with undecided or low-information voters. While fewer debates occur than in previous cycles, Craig Hennigan from the University of Nevada suggests an unmet demand, as seen in the popularity of alternative debate formats.

The midterm campaign trail involves several pivotal events, from President Trump’s rallies to candidate debates across the country, keeping voters and political enthusiasts engaged.

TAGS: