The Justice Department has approached the Supreme Court to temporarily halt decisions by lower courts that refused its plea to set aside more than 20,000 mail-in ballots from California. These ballots, according to the department, were cast by individuals likely not holding U.S. citizenship.
Arguing for a limited injunction, the DOJ contends it will safeguard these ballots while investigations into their legitimacy are conducted without canceling valid votes. A disagreement exists between California and the federal government regarding the legality of these ballots.
The DOJ stated, “Once illegally cast ballots are counted and mixed with lawful ones, the resultant harm cannot be remedied.”
The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals turned down the request on Friday, with Judge Patrick Bumatay dissenting. A federal judge in Los Angeles also denied the request. The DOJ is pursuing relief as the case is ongoing.
California argues that its safeguards against noncitizen voting are strong and highlights potential errors in federal lists, which could lead to the disenfranchisement of eligible voters. The lower courts emphasized a state’s control over election procedures and warned that granting the DOJ’s request could compromise the election process.
The case is rooted in a lawsuit filed by the Justice Department on October 15, alleging that California obstructs the enforcement of a federal law preventing noncitizens from participating in federal elections. The administration insists California has contravened the Constitution’s Supremacy Clause, generally allowing federal law to override state law.
This legal conflict emerges amid wider efforts by the administration to impact state-run election processes, including calls for access to voter registries and cautioning officials against knowingly allowing noncitizens to vote.
In California, the nation’s most populated state, 52 House seats are contested. Democrats require a net gain of four seats to capture control of the chamber.
