President Donald Trump’s legal team expressed satisfaction as a U.S. District Judge denied a motion by The New York Times to dismiss Trump’s $15 billion defamation lawsuit against the publication. The case focuses on claims of criminal conduct that Trump argues the Times and Penguin Random House ignored facts in their publications.
Judge Steven D. Merryday ruled that four counts related to seven accusations could continue. Trump’s legal representative stated, “President Trump is holding the Fake News accountable for misleading the public,” emphasizing the ruling’s significance in promoting truthfulness in America.
The judge directed criticism at journalists Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner, authors of a book about Trump’s handling of family wealth. They accused Trump of tax fraud and laundering without sufficient evidence, lacking legal or forensic findings.
Merryday noted the allegations against Trump and his father lacked formal charges, stating, “The complaint suggests the authors and publishers did not perform due diligence, failing to verify claims through substantial research and expert opinion.” This oversight failed to confirm their allegations against Trump.
The court dismissed The New York Times’ citations of opinions from external analysts, including former prosecutors and academics. Merryday clarified that such non-expert opinions do not meet the standard needed to support serious accusations, explaining that vague statements do not equate to factual legal accusations.
Trump’s lawsuit proceeds, though two counts were dismissed, along with 27 statements considered protected under First Amendment precedents like New York Times Co. v. Sullivan. Trump was also denied a chance to revise his complaint again.
The New York Times spokesperson responded, “We are encouraged by the dismissal of most claims and maintain the remaining claim has no merit.” The publication remains committed to defending itself against the lawsuit, viewing it as an unreasonable challenge to press freedoms.
The court ordered The New York Times to respond formally within 28 days. The legal proceedings continue, with both parties set to present their arguments in defense of their respective positions.
