In Utah, the judge presiding over the trial of the man accused of killing conservative podcaster Charlie Kirk stated Monday that there could be flexibility in applying the defendant’s constitutional rights during preliminary hearings.
Judge Tony Graf Jr. addressed the court in Provo regarding the evidence and testimony permissible in Tyler Robinson’s trial. Robinson, 23, requested that hearsay not be used to establish probable cause and that his former roommate testify in person.
Graf noted that Utah’s constitution permits hearsay evidence, asserting that “a relaxed application of defendants’ constitutional rights” is appropriate at this stage, emphasizing that this is not the full trial.
Robinson, charged with aggravated murder for the September 10, 2025, shooting of Kirk at Utah Valley University, has not yet entered a plea. Charlie Kirk’s death occurred while he spoke at the university.
Robinson’s attorneys have not provided comments when contacted by Newsweek via email.
Robinson’s Requests
Robinson sought to have his former roommate testify in person during the preliminary hearing. The defendant reportedly texted his roommate, indicating he targeted Kirk due to perceived hate, as prosecutors state. The defense argued against using recorded statements, wanting the roommate to testify so Robinson could confront and challenge their credibility.
Judge Graf denied this request, indicating that witness challenging would occur later. Robinson also opposed hearsay evidence presented by the prosecution. Graf remarked that a preliminary hearing is distinct from a trial, focusing on evidence presentation, not determining guilt or innocence.
There was no immediate ruling on whether prosecutors might face sanctions for media comments regarding a bullet fragment found on Kirk’s body.
Next Steps
The preliminary hearing for Robinson will proceed in July, with a full trial scheduled later. If found guilty, Robinson could face the death penalty, which his defense team aims to avoid.
This story will continue to be updated as more information becomes available.
Reporting includes contributions from The Associated Press.