Disney and ABC have accused the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) of bypassing “judicial review” to exert “maximal coercive pressure” against their network and company. The accusations arose during a dispute over the agency’s decision to bring forward broadcast license renewals for eight ABC-owned stations. Disney initially filed a lawsuit against the FCC in August, claiming the agency’s actions represented a “retaliatory campaign against ABC.”
The FCC requires stations to demonstrate that they operate in the public interest, which includes investigations into diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) practices. Disney contends that the FCC could have used other methods to review these practices without expediting the license renewal process, a move the company views as an attempt to evade legal scrutiny.
“These are not merely ‘theoretical’ tools… they have been used by the agency for decades,” stated Disney in their recent filing.
The current request for early license renewals is unprecedented, according to Disney, who suggest the aim is to exert coercive pressure on the media company to curtail its speech. In a recent court hearing, the FCC was advised to present additional ways it might have conducted its investigation. The agency argued that any alternative actions would require enforcement at the federal court level.
Disney views the FCC’s process as part of a retaliatory strategy intended to shield an unconstitutional campaign from judicial review. FCC spokesperson Adam Jackman dismissed these claims, asserting that Disney filed the case in the wrong court and at the wrong time.
“They want a district court to prevent the FCC from even considering whether Disney has complied with its longstanding obligations as a broadcaster. The law does not allow that,” Jackman commented.
Disney asserts that the FCC’s investigations are a form of retaliation against ABC for programs and hosts critical of former President Donald Trump, such as Jimmy Kimmel. The FCC has also launched a probe into ABC’s “The View,” challenging whether the talk show complies with equal opportunity requirements for political candidates. Disney defends “The View” as a “bona fide news” program, claiming exemption from those rules.
