November 5, 2026

Decades-Old Murder Case Resurfaces

Paula Turley last spoke to her friend Karen Snider on the morning of November 12, 1966. They discussed feeding their baby daughters and Turley’s upcoming birthday, Turley, now 79, testified on Wednesday. “We talked every morning,” she said.

That night, 18-year-old Snider was found stabbed to death in her Calumet City home. At the time, Turley was married to James Barbier, who was recently arrested in Missouri in 2024. He was charged with first-degree murder in connection with Snider’s death after the case had gone cold for many years. His trial began on Tuesday.

Barbier was a co-worker of Snider’s husband at the Indiana Harbor Belt Railroad. The two couples were good friends, according to Turley. Both women had daughters in August 1966. “She was my best friend,” Turley stated in court.

Later that same day, Turley recalled her parents and brother visiting her at her home in Gary, Indiana. They were in the kitchen when she noticed Barbier returning home around dusk. Though she didn’t see him enter, she knew he was home when she heard the washing machine operating in the basement. This was atypical, as he never did laundry. She only saw him when he came upstairs. “He was in clean clothes then,” she noted. “He had cuts on his face.”

Cook County Chief Medical Examiner Ponni Arunkumar shared details about Snider’s injuries. Stabbed more than 120 times, Snider had 18 wounds to her neck and additional injuries to her chest and abdomen, according to the autopsy. “Many of them did go through ribs and entered the ribcage,” Arunkumar testified.

Arunkumar explained that the neck wounds damaged Snider’s larynx, jugular vein, and carotid artery, with some cuts reaching her spine. The abdominal injuries affected her heart, aorta, and liver. Defensive wounds were also present on her hands.

At Snider’s funeral, Barbier acted as a pallbearer, Turley revealed. His face was bandaged at that time. After Snider’s death, Barbier moved to Missouri, and the couple divorced a year later. Turley mentioned she never received financial support from him post-divorce.

Assistant Public Defender Tom Justic challenged Turley’s recollection of the events from 60 years ago, citing inconsistencies in her testimonies. “You don’t have much memory of Nov. 12, 1966, at all, do you?” Justic questioned.

He pointed out that Turley previously claimed to have seen Barbier come home, contrasting with her current statement. Her descriptions of his facial injuries had also varied in past interviews.

On Tuesday, the trial heard from former Chicago police Capt. John Collins, now 91, who processed the crime scene in 1966 without gloves, a standard practice at the time. Collins admitted to being unfamiliar with DNA technology back then. The photos taken at the scene were in black and white.

The trial continues at the Markham Courthouse.

TAGS: