Democrat Xavier Becerra and Republican Steve Hilton faced off in their only planned debate for California governor. This debate provided voters a glimpse into their differing visions for the state’s future. According to a UC Berkeley Institute poll, Becerra leads Hilton 58% to 33% with voters highlighting the high cost of living as a rising concern. Additional analysis was provided by Times columnists Gustavo Arellano, Anita Chabria, and Mark Z. Barabak.
Becerra vs. Hilton: Political Positions
The candidates debated for 60 minutes in Burbank. Hilton, a candidate with limited chances, focused on optimistic messaging. His slogans included ‘Make California Gold Again!’ and ‘Califordable!’ Meanwhile, Becerra criticized Hilton’s approach and highlighted his own plans for public education and state government functions.
Education Debate
The issue of California’s troubled education system arose with questions about what each candidate would do to improve student outcomes. Becerra criticized the state’s uncoordinated education system. He praised recent developments, such as transitional kindergarten, while warning that Hilton would divert taxpayer money to private schools. On the other hand, Hilton blamed Democratic leadership for educational shortcomings, suggesting he is not sponsored by teachers’ unions, which he views as part of the problem.
Immigration and Housing
The debate also addressed immigration, with Hilton attacking Becerra’s management of unaccompanied minors during the pandemic. Becerra defended his efforts and questioned Hilton’s immigration policies. As for housing, Hilton accused Becerra of failing to reduce housing costs. Becerra countered by highlighting a legal victory against Huntington Beach to enforce housing laws.
Elections and Homelessness
A notable discussion was on Proposition 39, a voter ID initiative that Hilton supports. Becerra opposes it, calling it an obstacle to voting. Further debate focused on homelessness, with Becerra promising accountability and investment in mental health services, while Hilton criticized him for lack of improvement in homelessness, citing his support for Gov. Newsom.
Artificial Intelligence and Economic Policies
AI policies and job preservation arose when CNN’s Dana Bash asked Hilton about self-policing in tech sectors. Becerra critiqued Hilton’s approach, referencing President Trump’s past meetings with tech leaders. Both candidates agreed on regulations for AI and data centers. Economic discussions included Hilton’s tax plans, which Becerra asserted would harm education and other essential state services.
Debate Analysis and Political Influence
Throughout the event, connections to former President Trump and his policies were discussed, with Becerra frequently pointing to Hilton’s affiliation with him. Becerra also plans to maintain liberal policies opposing Trump. The debate highlighted the candidates’ differing approaches to California’s challenges and showcased their readiness to address voter priorities such as cost of living and governmental policies.