November 11, 2026

BYU’s Victory and Utah’s Rise in College Football

The 2026 college football season saw a pivotal match where the BYU Cougars triumphed over the Notre Dame Fighting Irish in Provo. This victory significantly enhanced BYU’s standing, demonstrating the Big 12 Conference’s national relevance. BYU immediately became a contender for the College Football Playoff, asserting their position as a top-5 or top-10 team. However, their subsequent loss to a middling UCF team in Florida diminished some of the excitement leading to their game against the Utah Utes on November 7.

Despite the setback, the “Holy War” between BYU and Utah showcased both teams as leading contenders nationally. Although Utah emerged victorious with a score of 28-20, the game reflected intense competition, emphasizing the strength of Big 12 teams.

During this thrilling encounter, Utah’s quarterback, Devon Dampier, played a crucial role, propelling Utah to No. 2 in the latest AP Top 25 Poll, right behind the Georgia Bulldogs. With a 9-0 record in a Power 4 conference, including wins over the Houston Cougars and BYU, Utah is favored to reach today’s playoffs and possibly secure a first-round bye. Their path to the National Championship appears promising.

Nonetheless, there is some skepticism. ESPN’s senior analyst Heather Didich, known for her support of the SEC, expressed doubts on ESPN’s “Get Up” show. She argued that Utah’s position is partly due to other teams losing, and although they have a skilled quarterback, Dampier, their struggle against Colorado raises questions about their overall strength.

Dan Didich highlighted BYU quarterback Bear Bachmeier’s errors, including four interceptions and numerous penalties, which contributed to Utah’s win. She questioned Utah’s capabilities against top teams like Georgia.

Paul Finebaum echoed this sentiment, openly stating that Utah isn’t capable of clinching the national championship. The comparisons made to Georgia are notable, considering Georgia’s losses, such as their home defeat to Auburn, which has a less favorable 5-4 record this season.

Critics dismiss a close game against Colorado for Utah but overlook Georgia’s occasional slip-ups, indicating a potential bias. ESPN’s SP+ provides an objective view through an efficiency-driven ranking system, highlighting contenders and their potential. According to SP+, Utah ranks No. 9, just behind Alabama at No. 8. If Alabama is viewed as a contender, so should Utah.

Ultimately, whether Utah secures a championship is uncertain as the path through the playoff can be unpredictable. The apparent bias against Utah may stem more from conference affiliation than actual performance. If Utah bore a different emblem, they might be considered for the top spot quicker. Ian Miller has reported from OutKick.

TAGS: