Jennifer Sey, founder of XX-XY Athletics, is taking legal action against Colorado, arguing that a state law could threaten her company’s core values. XX-XY Athletics focuses on protecting women’s sports, and Sey believes the law might force her business to abandon its principles.
Attorney Hal Frampton, representing XX-XY Athletics, highlighted the law’s potential consequences. Violations of Colorado’s anti-discrimination law could incur fines of up to $3,500 per offense. Certain advertising violations might lead to a Class 2 misdemeanor, punishable by up to 120 days in jail. Although the state hasn’t enforced the law against the company since its enactment in 2025, Sey remains skeptical of potential future actions.
Sey, previously a senior executive at Levi Strauss & Co., disagreed with COVID lockdown measures in 2020. In March 2020, she launched XX-XY Athletics with the mission to protect women’s sports.
Why have the law if it’s not enforced? I don’t trust you,
said Sey, referring to Colorado’s stance that enforcement hasn’t occurred yet. The law in question, the Kelly Loving Act (HB 25-1312) from 2025, broadens anti-discrimination protections to include a person’s chosen name and pronouns. Sey and her lawyers argue this could compel businesses to use language against their beliefs.
XX-XY Athletics actively voices its position on biological sex. In recent campaigns, the company opposed biological males participating in female sports. Earlier this month, Sey successfully supported Proposition 134, which Colorado voters approved with 52% support. The measure categorizes sports teams into male, female, or coed, based on biological sex. It becomes effective on January 1.
Despite this success, Sey remains concerned about discussing such issues under the current law. How can we talk about the law itself with these speech restrictions?
Sey questioned. Her attorneys contend that the expanded gender expression definition might expose the company to discrimination complaints based on their statements.
Frampton emphasized that waiting for a complaint isn’t viable. Sey fears that mandated language use could undermine the company’s mission. In March, a federal judge denied XX-XY Athletics’ preliminary injunction request, acknowledging no credible threat of enforcement yet. The ruling didn’t address the First Amendment, but noted insufficient grounds for immediate protection.
Colorado argues the threat is overstated. During a hearing, Janna Fischer, representing Colorado, said plaintiffs seek to freely misgender or deadname without repercussions. The state asserts no substantive rights under the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act (CADA) were altered by the legislation.
Sey views the stakes as universal, affecting all businesses and individuals. The dispute arises amid past Colorado court cases involving free speech. The U.S. Supreme Court previously sided with Colorado baker Jack Phillips in 2018’s Masterpiece Cakeshop case, citing state officials’ bias against his religious beliefs. In 303 Creative, the court ruled against compelling a web designer to create content against her beliefs. This year, in Chiles v. Salazar, the justices supported a Colorado counselor challenging conversational restrictions.
Frampton referenced these cases, questioning Colorado’s approach. Meanwhile, Governor-elect Phil Weiser indicates Proposition 134 might face revisions, as lawmakers could change the statute. Sey, instrumental in passing Proposition 134, doubts such moves would be politically favorable, stating she’d publicize any efforts to overturn the people’s will.
