November 9, 2026

Alaska Senate Race Hinges on Uncounted Ballots and Ranked Choices

Alaska’s U.S. Senate race remains undecided, with a duplicate name on the ballot potentially affecting the outcome. As of November 8, the vote count had been unchanged since November 4. From 215,906 ballots, Democrat Mary Peltola leads Republican Senator Dan S. Sullivan by 637 first-choice votes. Neither candidate has reached 50%, and if no one does by November 18, ranked choice votes will be counted.

Ballot Confusion and Legal Challenges

A second Dan Sullivan, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. from Petersburg, received 3,600 votes, impacting the initial count. More voters who selected him preferred Peltola as their next choice over Senator Sullivan. The state faces legal scrutiny, as a federal judge dismissed a lawsuit on November 1 aimed at preventing confusion over the two Sullivans.

Governor Mike Dunleavy has initiated an investigation into allegations that Peltola’s supporters intentionally recruited Sullivan Jr. Both parties deny these claims. A measure to repeal ranked choice voting is also being reviewed, adding complexity to the election.

Uncounted Ballots and the Path Forward

Approximately 51,000 early and absentee ballots await counting, with additional mail ballots expected to arrive. If no candidate surpasses 50% with all ballots counted, ranked choices will be considered starting November 18. Newsweek reached out to both campaign teams for comments regarding a close finish that factors in Sullivan Jr.’s votes.

Estimating the Remaining Count

As of November 4, numbers from Alaska’s ballot report have helped estimate the outstanding ballots. Rejected absentee ballots will remain uncounted. Another 10,528 absentee ballots are still pending return. Domestic mail ballots can be received until November 13 and overseas ballots until November 18.

Projected Outcomes Based on Current Data

“Newsweek used the scanned ballots’ rankings to estimate how second choices would move, then applied those rates to the state’s full totals.”

The process involves removing the candidate with the fewest votes and reallocating according to those voters’ next preferences. Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. will likely be the first to drop out, reallocating about 1,040 votes to Peltola and 590 to Senator Sullivan. This may shift Peltola’s lead.

Following second-choice dispositions, Senator Sullivan may edge Peltola by approximately 333 votes, as estimated by Newsweek. These figures offer a prediction, not official results.

Looking Ahead

Final results hinge on the remaining ballots. To win outright and avoid ranked choice, a candidate must secure over 50% of first-choice votes. Should 10,000 additional mail ballots be counted, the thresholds adjust accordingly. If leftover ballots split evenly, Newsweek’s model favors a slight lead for Senator Sullivan. Peltola requires more than a 0.7 percentage point advantage to overcome this estimate.

Analysis of already counted early and absentee ballots showed a 56.5% preference for Peltola initially, shifting to 58% after ranked choice adjustments. These figures offer insight but not guaranteed outcomes due to potential differences in forthcoming mail ballot trends.

TAGS: