November 5, 2026

Comparing College Basketball Rankings: Human Polls vs. Analytics

College basketball has returned along with the series “CBB With Danny Z.” Many fans only recognize the sport in late winter. Last season, comparisons between the preseason AP Top 25 and KenPom’s rankings provided insights. This exercise was revisited in December, January, and March to evaluate developments.

Note: The page may contain affiliate links to legal sports betting partners, and FOX News may receive compensation for sign-ups or wagers. The content creation team operates independently from the FOX newsroom.

UCONN Basketball Coach Considered a White House Game After a UFC Event

KenPom’s predictions shined for Vanderbilt last season, ranking them 19th, in contrast to the AP’s effective 36th placement. Vanderbilt concluded the season 27-9, earning a No. 5 seed and winning an NCAA Tournament game. However, KenPom’s optimistic look at Baylor, placing them 17th, didn’t pan out as expected, as Baylor finished 17-17 and missed the tournament. KenPom was early on the 2025-26 Vanderbilt Commodores.

St. John’s served as a cautionary tale against early conclusions. Ranked 5th by AP and 16th by KenPom, their start at 4-3 appeared to validate KenPom until the Red Storm finished 30-7, reaching the Sweet 16 and nearly upsetting Duke. Creighton was ranked 23rd by AP and placed 41st by KenPom, but their season ended in disappointment with a 16-18 record and a lower-tier tournament appearance.

Analyzing Polls and Analytics

This year includes a broader view with TeamRankings’ ratings and the Coaches Poll. Controversies arise from discrepancies between human polls and analytics models. The comparisons draw from the preseason AP and Coaches Polls and analytics models’ ratings from the morning of November 1.

Kansas and Iowa State: A Computer’s Affection

The top-ranking teams showcase little debate: Florida and Duke switch places between polls and analytics, while Illinois remains stable. Kansas emerges as a surprise. While Kansas is ranked 17th in the AP and tied for 18th in the Coaches Poll, KenPom positions them fifth, and TeamRankings places them sixth. The computers appreciate Bill Self’s team more than human voters.

Iowa State also experiences discrepancies. Despite being a No. 2 seed in 2026, the team is ranked 18th by the AP and tied for 14th by the coaches, but KenPom and TeamRankings rank them sixth and 11th, respectively, with their defense being a key factor.

Additionally, Alabama looks favorable in analytics: 20th in AP, 18th in Coaches, but ninth in KenPom with a projected fourth-best offense.

Human Polls Favor Tennessee and USC

USC receives differing views, ranking 21st in the AP and 22nd in the Coaches, while neither analytics model places them in the top 35. Tennessee shows variance too, being eighth in the AP and ninth in Coaches, but 22nd in KenPom, reversing last year’s analytic preference for them. Arkansas, ranked 12th in the AP and 13th by coaches, appears 19th in KenPom.

Both human polls include BYU at 25th, whereas KenPom and TeamRankings leave them outside the top 25.

Nebraska Garners Analytical Interest

Nebraska surprised both polls last year by climbing into the top 15. This year, KenPom starts them at 15th and TeamRankings at 22nd. Human polls position Nebraska as effectively 27th in the AP and 26th among coaches. Their last season ended with a historic Sweet 16 appearance.

Ohio State presents another case: 18th in KenPom, but 31st in TeamRankings.

Vanderbilt and UConn: Computer Division

Vanderbilt reflects prior disagreements, with KenPom favoring them at 12th, while AP ranks them 24th. UConn, following national championship appearances, is fourth in the AP and fifth among coaches, yet 11th in KenPom. TeamRankings shows confidence by placing them third.

Louisville is found 11th in both human polls, with KenPom at 16th and TeamRankings at ninth.

The article aims to continually follow these ranking variations as the season progresses.

If any insights regarding “CBB With Danny Z” need to be added in future articles, readers are encouraged to contact the reporter at [email protected] or on social media at @RealDanZak.

TAGS: