October 15, 2026

Alignment Healthcare Sues CMS Over Medicare Ratings

Alignment Healthcare’s Legal Action

Alignment Healthcare, a significant Medicare Advantage insurer, has sued the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) over its 2027 star ratings. The dispute, filed in federal court in Washington, D.C., claims that CMS unlawfully calculated the ratings, potentially costing Alignment hundreds of millions of dollars.

The company argues that CMS used the same ten measures for its 2027 Star Ratings without first establishing them through the mandated federal rulemaking process. This legal question is also central to Alignment’s ongoing challenge to its 2026 star ratings.

“Once again, CMS has used the same ten measures in calculating Alignment’s 2027 Star Ratings without first promulgating them ‘by regulation,’ as Congress expressly required,” the complaint states.

If the ratings remain unchanged, Alignment fears a financial loss exceeding $200 million in 2028.

Why Star Ratings Matter

Medicare Advantage star ratings, ranging from one to five stars, significantly impact both insurers and beneficiaries. They guide consumers in comparing the quality of plans and influence the qualification for substantial quality bonus payments. A change of even half a star, which happened to Alignment, can lead to major financial repercussions.

The insurer’s complaint noted, “The financial consequences from just a single half-star change in a plan’s overall Star Rating can easily amount to hundreds of millions of dollars for an individual plan.”

Current Ratings and Impact

CMS released the 2027 star ratings on October 8. Alignment’s California HMO contract dropped from four stars to 3.5 stars. More notably, the percentage of Alignment members in plans receiving at least four stars plummeted from 98% in 2026 to 25% in 2027.

Financial literacy instructor Alex Beene shared with Newsweek, “The substantial decline raises questions about whether the government’s evaluation process is consistent, transparent, and accurately reflects the quality of care beneficiaries receive.”

The Legal Argument

Alignment operates Medicare Advantage plans across five states and wants the court to overturn its 2027 ratings. The company contends that CMS established critical elements of its rating methodology via “technical notes” rather than following the formal notice-and-comment rulemaking required by the Administrative Procedure Act.

A company spokesperson stated, “Our lawsuit seeks to ensure that the Star Ratings program operates as Congress intended and that Alignment is properly compensated for the care we provide.”

CMS’s Previous Legal Challenges

A previous court challenge in Georgia found ten measures used by CMS to be beyond its statutory authority. Another ten were deemed procedurally invalid. CMS recalculated the 2026 ratings following this litigation. However, according to Alignment, the agency continued using contested measures for its 2027 ratings.

Michael Ryan, a finance expert, told Newsweek, “Its argument is that CMS used rating measures without following the legally required rulemaking process. That’s a serious question, but it doesn’t automatically mean the rating is wrong.”

Implications for Medicare Beneficiaries

The lawsuit focuses on how Alignment’s plan ratings impact the financial compensation the insurer receives through the Medicare Advantage system. Star ratings are crucial for consumers as they affect plan comparisons and insurers’ eligibility for quality-related payments.

“Ultimately, the greatest concern is for seniors who rely on these plans,” said Beene. Reductions in federal payments might result in fewer supplemental benefits and increased out-of-pocket costs.

Future Developments

Alignment aims to have its 2027 star ratings recalculated. The financial stakes will continue into 2028 when payments influenced by the ratings take effect. “A courtroom victory could restore an insurer’s bonus payments without proving patients received better care,” Ryan explained.

He added, “We’re treating a financial rating dispute as though it automatically settles a healthcare quality dispute. It doesn’t.” Medicare beneficiaries need clarity on whether there were actual improvements or declines in care quality before trusting any party’s statements.

TAGS: