A judge in Texas has rejected a motion for a new trial for Karmelo Anthony, convicted of murder in the death of 17-year-old Austin Metcalf at a high school track meet. The incident brought national focus and led to harassment of families involved.
Anthony, now 19, was found guilty in June and received a 35-year prison sentence for the killing that occurred in April 2025. Judge Michael Chitty issued a brief order denying the retrial request near Dallas after a two-day hearing, citing a review of the presented evidence and arguments without further detail.
Russell Wilson, Anthony’s lawyer, plans to appeal the decision, stating, “Our commitment to our client has not changed. We will continue to advocate vigorously on his behalf through every lawful avenue available.” The defense’s request for a retrial centered around an informal agreement between prosecutors and defenders to exclude damaging character evidence during the original trial.
This mutual decision aimed to prevent further escalation of a case already charged with racial tensions. Social media amplified racial aspects due to Anthony being Black and Metcalf white, although lawyers on both sides instructed jurors that race was not a factor.
The defense argued their strategy shifted when concerns arose about prosecutors violating the agreement, leading Anthony not to testify. Prosecutor Bill Wirskye defended the fairness of the trial, with District Attorney Greg Willis affirming confidence in the court’s decision while respecting Anthony’s right to appeal. “The jury’s guilty verdict stands, and our thoughts and prayers remain with the Metcalf family,” Willis stated.
Anthony’s legal team also contested the courtroom’s public access restrictions, requesting Judge John Roach’s recusal due to his posttrial comments supporting the jury’s decision in a TV interview. Roach maintained his rules ensured trial fairness, while prosecutors claimed no wrongdoing occurred.
During the trial, jurors dismissed Anthony’s self-defense claims regarding the altercation with Metcalf in the bleachers at the track meet. According to witnesses, Metcalf repeatedly told Anthony to leave. Prosecutors argued that Anthony was the aggressor, with witnesses recalling him issuing a threat before being pushed by Metcalf. Anthony is reported to have responded by stabbing Metcalf in the chest.