Even with modern technology like ABS and instant replay, controversy in sports is alive and well. Baltimore Orioles fans, players, coaches, and announcers were incensed following a ruling on Pete Alonso’s potential home run during a game against the New York Yankees.
On Wednesday night, an initial call declared Alonso’s go-ahead blast foul, although it appeared to be his 30th home run of the season. With the game tied at 3 in the seventh inning, Alonso sent a ball down the left field line and started his trot to first base.
Baltimore Orioles designated hitter Pete Alonso reacts during an official review after his seventh-inning hit against the New York Yankees at Oriole Park at Camden Yards on August 19, 2026. The review confirmed the call of a foul ball. (Getty Images)
The umpires reviewed the play, yet maintained their initial decision, stating simply, “the call on the field stands.” This common explanation often implies uncertainty regarding a definitive call.
Opinions on the call were divided, with Orioles players asserting data supported the hit as a home run. Commentator Michael Kay from the Yankees broadcast voiced his uncertainty, noting, “That looks fair.” When even the opposing broadcaster concedes doubt, the initial call appears questionable.
The decision faced scrutiny due to its potential impact on the game’s outcome. Had umpires initially ruled the hit fair, experts believe few would have raised objections. The viewing angles available to the Yankees’ dugout, situated down the third base line, may have also limited their perspective.
Orioles manager Craig Albernaz mentioned the team’s use of ball-tracking data on iPads, which convinced them the hit was fair. “It’s 2026. Technology has advanced significantly. Other sports use AI and ball-tracking data for challenges. I don’t understand why we don’t,” Albernaz stated. Despite lamenting the call, he clarified it’s not why they lost.
The Yankees ended up winning 5-3, partly due to two runs scored in the eighth inning. Had Alonso’s hit been ruled a home run, the game’s dynamics might have shifted, with the Orioles leading into the eighth.
The call continues to kindle debates about the efficacy of current technologies in umpiring decisions.