Fox News reporter Matt Finn covers the preliminary hearing of Tyler Robinson in Provo, Utah. Robinson is charged with the assassination of Charlie Kirk, with prosecutors presenting evidence including video testimony and text message confessions. Retired FBI agent James Gagliano discusses the Kirk family’s wish for transparency as the hearing is broadcast.

Prosecution’s Stance

Prosecutors assert Robinson rarely hit his target accurately during practice with the supposed murder weapon. This argument opposes the defense’s request to remove the death penalty from consideration before trial. They argue Robinson’s actions placed others at risk by shooting from a rooftop towards a large crowd. Kirk, while answering questions on stage, was shot in the neck.

Defense’s Argument

Robinson’s defense claims the shot did not pass through the crowd. They highlight that only one shot was fired, hitting the intended target without harming bystanders.

Legal Filings

Prosecutors need to establish an aggravating factor for the death penalty. They argue the shooting endangered others, and Robinson was aware of the risk. The defense aims to dismiss this aggravator, potentially removing the death penalty risk.

The allegations surfaced in a recent public reply to earlier defense filings. The case’s probable cause was debated in a week-long hearing in early July, with Judge Tony Graf Jr.’s decision expected by September 1.

Prosecutors’ Claims

Prosecutors argue Robinson’s case should proceed to trial and accuse the defense of neglecting basic case law regarding evidence evaluation. They suggest the magistrate must draw reasonable inferences in the state’s favor, positing that the shooting posed a danger to bystanders.

Robinson has not yet submitted a plea.

Incident Timeline

Surveillance shows Robinson traveling from southern Utah to Orem. He allegedly shot Kirk during a Turning Point USA event at Utah Valley University in September 2025. After admitting his actions to several individuals, he turned himself in to authorities.