While St. Francis boasts impressive football results, its reality contrasts with that of its private school counterparts. Last weekend, St. Francis fielded about 30 players during their trip to suburban Indianapolis to face New Palestine, the two-time defending Indiana state champions. New Palestine had double the number of players. This situation is familiar for the Spartans, who celebrated their Class 5A state championship last year.

Coach Bob McMillen’s tenure has been transformative for St. Francis. His leadership saw the school overcome two 1-8 seasons when he joined in 2017. The turn-around became evident with victories like their 2024 win against Loyola, Chicago’s largest private school. St. Francis player Peyton Shipley recalled the disparity in team sizes during that game. “We had about 35 guys warming up, and they had around 130,” Shipley said. Despite the odds, St. Francis won 35-21, while Loyola later claimed the 8A state championship.

McMillen credits the program’s resurgence to committed coaches and finding students who fit well with the team. Coming from IC Catholic in Elmhurst, McMillen understands the dynamics of a small school achieving big victories. St. Francis, with its 684 students, is larger than Montini and IC Catholic, both known for their competitive edge.

Senior kicker Evan Kolinski finds value in the small-school environment. “I formed closer bonds with teammates because we shared every class,” he noted. These bonds extend beyond the football field, contributing to their success. St. Francis’s football practices, held on a distinctive black-and-blue turf, showcase their unique spirit. The school, one of the few endorsed by Battle Sports, offers an array of uniforms and helmets, providing an experience similar to Oregon’s high school program.

Quarterback development has been key for St. Francis. Alumni like Tommy Rittenhouse and Alessio Milivojevic have made significant impacts at Illinois State and Michigan State, respectively. Last week against New Palestine, QB Jadon Wilson’s injury highlighted the Spartans’ need for adaptability when their lead of 17-7 slipped away.

Senior running back Tivias Caldwell Jr. demonstrated the team’s resilience with an 80-yard touchdown run just before halftime secured a 10-point lead. Having grown up near St. Francis, Caldwell appreciates the team’s camaraderie and spirit. “This field was my youth team’s base, and the bond here was unmatched,” he expressed. St. Francis thrives on the belief that all it takes is 11 dedicated players on their iconic field.