Understanding the Role of the Insurance Commissioner
This election season includes a crucial yet often overlooked public office: the insurance commissioner of California. Democratic candidates Ben Allen and Jane Kim compete for this position, leading the California Department of Insurance, the largest state consumer protection agency in the U.S.
With 1,400 employees, the department supervises 1,600 insurance companies and more than 510,000 agents, brokers, adjusters, bail agents, and business entities. The office regulates various insurance types, including home, car, health, life, pet insurance, worker’s compensation, ride-hailing, and Medigap insurance.
The current commissioner, Ricardo Lara, is termed-out, leaving the role vital for voter decision.
Insights on the Position
Former Insurance Commissioner Dave Jones, serving from 2011 to 2019, shared his views on the demands and significance of the role. Today, he directs the Climate Risk Initiative at the UC Berkeley Center for Law, Energy & the Environment.
Jones highlighted the position’s extensive reach, stating its impact on daily issues like health insurance. The commissioner has authority over home and small-business property insurance rates. Insurers must file rates and justify increases, a unique requirement compared to other states.
Jones pointed out the part insurance rate hikes play in the affordability crisis, such as when property owners pass increased insurance costs down to renters.
Challenges in Insurance Coverage
One major issue is the high rate of coverage denials in California, driving up reliance on the Fair Access to Insurance Requirements Plan (FAIR Plan) for fire coverage. This plan acts as a last-resort pool for homeowners unable to secure traditional coverage. FAIR premiums typically exceed traditional ones.
In 2019, about 190,000 Californians were in the plan, with 74,000 new policies written that year. Additionally, insurers issued approximately 235,000 non-renewals and cancellations for homeowners and fire insurance.
By September, around 686,000 residents participated in the FAIR plan, growing modestly by 7% year-over-year. In prior years, growth rates were significantly higher, with increases of 39%, 40%, and 21%, respectively.
Another uncoventional solution is the Surplus Line Market. This unregulated option is often used for unusual insurance needs, such as skydiving schools or historic properties. By 2025, 300,000 Californians were expected to join this costly insurance alternative.
Jones stated that despite challenges like insurers leaving the state, the commissioner’s powers are limited.
Impact on California Residents
Insurance rate matters and coverage availability impose major hurdles for the incoming commissioner and legislators. Protecting homeowner insurance is a critical priority.
