When I agreed to consult with the Embassy of Qatar on education initiatives, criticism was expected. However, I did not anticipate the wave of falsehoods that would emerge. Qatar holds a significant, albeit complex role in the Middle East. My experience as a former Secretary of Education was intended to provide clarity about its educational activities.
I was surprised when a program intended to help American students learn Arabic was mischaracterized as an attempt to “infiltrate” U.S. schools. This argument was raised by critics concerned about Qatar Foundation International, which grants support to Arabic language programs in American schools. Yet, the reality is that the U.S. needs more language education, not less. This issue should be approached with factual scrutiny.
Under the Qatar Foundation International program, schools maintained control over their curriculum. The funding process was transparent, providing students with a legitimate chance to learn Arabic. Critics pointed to an incident at P.S. 261 in Brooklyn where a map labeled Israel as Palestine in a classroom. Despite Qatar Foundation International funding an Arabic program there, the map was unrelated to the organization. The city’s Chancellor, David Banks, clarified that the teacher privately acquired the map during a visit to Jerusalem.
A similar scenario occurred in New Haven, Connecticut, when the Foundation’s support of Arabic instruction was criticized by the Foundation for Defense of Democracies as a national security threat. However, Mayor Justin Elicker and Superintendent Madeline Negrón investigated and found that the program solely focused on teaching the Arabic language.
In June, Qatar Foundation International announced its exit from the U.S. after 17 years of support. Some critics, including those from the Institute for the Study of Global Antisemitism and Policy, wrongly celebrated this move. Instead, the loss of funding for Arabic instruction should concern us, because students need more opportunities in strategically important languages.
The bipartisan Commission on Language Learning from the American Academy of Arts and Sciences reported that language skills are vital for economic competitiveness, national security, and global engagement. They advised that every American child have a chance to learn a foreign language while recommending partnerships between schools, governments, philanthropies, businesses, and communities.
Arabic is a widely spoken language crucial to U.S. diplomacy, security, and business opportunities. Other countries engage with U.S. schools similarly: Germany, Spain, Italy, and Japan all support language programs in American schools. We don’t view these initiatives as foreign influence. They are resources that broaden student opportunities.
Qatar Foundation International’s grants shared this purpose, providing resources to learn Arabic. Transparency in funding is necessary, and school districts should retain curriculum control. Parents deserve to understand what their children are taught, devoid of political or religious motives, within public school language programs.
My personal experience further informs this debate. I recently resigned from the Middle East Media Research Institute after initially supporting its mission to translate Middle Eastern discourse. The organization shifted towards ideology, straying from its transparency objective, especially in its criticism of Qatar.
Arabic should coincide with languages like German, Spanish, Italian, or Japanese, free from political bias. More language education creates stronger foundations, offering better global understanding, with transparency and local control remaining paramount.
William J. Bennett is a former Secretary of Education.
