A recent study examines how fake smiles influence a person’s happiness. The phrase ‘fake it till you make it’ has evidence supporting its effectiveness. People who smile even when not feeling naturally inclined report higher happiness levels. Conversely, the study found varying outcomes when individuals are instructed or pressured to smile constantly.
Research led by Nicholas Coles, a psychology professor at the University of Florida, drew from his personal experience in customer service. Coles shared how working at a Florida theme park required him to maintain a smile for each customer despite negative interactions. This inspired his research into the effects of forced smiles.
Coles’ previous studies revealed that voluntary smiles, even in unlikely scenarios, can increase happiness. The impact remained significant even among those skeptical of smiling’s positive effects. However, the new study highlights that being forced to smile can decrease happiness instead.
What the Study Found
The study involved 1,200 participants in an online experiment. Participants viewed images with happy or unhappy themes and were asked to smile fakely or react naturally. When instructed to fake smiles, participants risked losing part of their $6 payment, though they all eventually received full payment. Participants reported their happiness after each round, showing that initial fake smiles boosted happiness, but repeated forced smiles diminished this effect.
Participants felt less happy and angrier when made to smile repeatedly, particularly under financial pressure, similar to Coles’ customer service role. Forced smiling aligned with emotional control in workplaces, undermining the concept of smiling for personal happiness. Coles emphasized that autonomy in choosing to smile is crucial for positive outcomes.
Psychology professor Norman Farb, not involved with the study, noted that posing smiles could balance emotional reactions. Positive images elevated happiness, while negative ones decreased it. Still, frequent forced smiling reduced mood and increased irritation, likened to the annoyance from a monitored task.
Implications of the Findings
Coles suggests that fake smiles can bring both joy and misery. Correlational evidence links emotional labor to negative psychological effects, and the study supports these claims with experimental evidence. Farb mentioned that repeated smiling under surveillance adds irritation and detracts attention from surrounding stimuli.
The research implies that forcing employees to smile is not an effective morale booster. Although smiling isn’t harmful, it’s ineffective without genuine emotional engagement. Required ‘service smiles’ bear potential long-term wellbeing costs, though the study doesn’t explore these effects.
For employers, encouraging constant smiling among staff isn’t a harmless morale booster, particularly under supervision. For individuals, smiling alone doesn’t replace true emotional connection.
