November 3, 2026

Supreme Court Weighs Catholic Schools’ Participation in Colorado Preschool Funding

The Supreme Court’s conservative majority demonstrated support for Catholic preschools in Colorado. These schools argue they are unjustly excluded from the state’s taxpayer-funded program due to alleged religious discrimination.

The core issue is whether these private schools, which admit only students from families aligning with Catholic beliefs, can be denied public benefits for not admitting children of LGBTQ+ parents. This case continues the thread of religious rights appeals reaching the Supreme Court, with several originating from Colorado.

“I’m hard-pressed to think that, given those [Catholic] teachings, that any homosexual family is going to choose to go to one of these schools, but that should be their choice, not your choice to exclude them,” Justice Sonia Sotomayor stated during oral arguments.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh proposed that the state’s demands promote a form of conformity, presenting a solution that appears unnecessary in this context.

Colorado’s Universal Preschool Program was setup through a 2020 ballot measure, distributing public funds to participating schools. Schools must offer equal enrollment opportunities, regardless of race, ethnicity, religious affiliation, sexual orientation, gender identity, income level, or disability.

The archdiocese in Colorado, which manages 34 preschools, claims they only admit students from families supporting Catholic ideology, particularly regarding same-sex marriage and gender identity. They view the state law as discriminatory toward their religious practices and claim this violates the First Amendment.

The state maintains its funding conditions are neutrally applied across all preschools. Each participant receives a $6,300 annual benefit per child for preschool services, funded by a tobacco tax.

The Supreme Court will contemplate altering a longstanding precedent stating religious practices do not automatically exempt entities from laws of general applicability. Debates during oral arguments highlighted ideological divides, with conservative justices leaning towards protecting religious exercise claims.

Chief Justice John Roberts could play a key role given his critical questioning of both sides. Roberts suggested Colorado’s law might be applied fairly, contrary to previous cases of direct discrimination against religious institutions.

Erika Nagle, associated with St. Mary Catholic School, expressed concerns regarding the exclusion from preschool funding based on Catholic beliefs.

“We are being excluded from this benefit because we are Catholic,” Nagle told Fox News Digital. “The state is incentivizing people to abandon their faith.”

The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, representing the plaintiffs, argued state policies have severe impacts, citing a 20% enrollment decrease and the closure of two schools.

The state counters that several religious entities continue participating without issue, maintaining that compliance is required from both religious and secular schools alike.

The case titled “St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy (25-581)” awaits a decision, expected by next spring.

TAGS: