Gun control advocates face concern when the Supreme Court reviews cases. This term amplifies that worry. Two cases, from Illinois and Connecticut, will be argued together in December. The issue: do the Second and Fourteenth Amendments protect rights to own AR-15 and similar rifles?
Gun rights groups feel confident the bans on semiautomatic rifles will be ruled unconstitutional. This follows the trend since 2008’s District of Columbia v. Heller, which confirmed individual firearm possession rights under the Second Amendment.
Later decisions extended these rights. In 2021, New York State Rifle and Pistol Association, Inc. v. Bruen deemed restrictions presumptively unconstitutional if conflicting with the amendment’s plain text.
The court rejected balancing government interests with individual rights. Bruen introduced a “history and tradition” test. Gun laws only pass if consistent with historical firearm regulation, ignoring modern firearms’ increased power.
Current cases involve laws from Connecticut and Illinois aimed at reducing semiautomatic rifle violence. On December 14, 2012, a gunman attacked Sandy Hook Elementary School in Connecticut, killing 26 people. Connecticut responded with laws restricting semiautomatic rifle sales and possession.
In Illinois, a parade sniper killed seven and injured many in Highland Park on July 4, 2022. Cook County reinforced a 2006 ordinance limiting assault-style weapons, now before the Supreme Court.
Numerous mass shootings have occurred in places like Uvalde, Aurora, and more, prompting legislative action against such weapons. The gun rights lobby opposes these efforts, citing Bruen, which dismisses evaluating the impact of firearm restrictions.
“The Second Amendment does not permit … judges to assess the costs and benefits of firearms restrictions.”
Hope remains, after U.S. v. Rahimi, where the court relaxed its “history and tradition” standard to prevent domestic abusers from accessing firearms.
Justice Kavanaugh might influence decisions on semiautomatic weapons. His opinion in Trump v. Barbara suggested that unexpected developments permit rights exceptions, potentially applying to firearm regulations.
Kavanaugh linked “unanticipated” developments to gun regulations, noting the proliferation of semiautomatic weapons as impactful for public safety. This reasoning contrasts with views treating the right to bear arms as akin to other constitutional rights.
The principle allowing exceptions under the 14th Amendment should also permit firearm restrictions under the Second Amendment.
Steven Lubet is a Professor Emeritus at Northwestern University Pritzker School of Law and coauthor of Judicial Conduct and Ethics.
Copyright 2026 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. No reproduction without permission.
