November 7, 2026

Sarah Pidgeon Reacts to Paul Anthony Kelly’s Latest Achievement

Sarah Pidgeon celebrated her co-star Paul Anthony Kelly’s recent accolade. Kelly, aged 38, was featured as the centerfold in PEOPLE’s 2026 Sexiest Man Alive issue. In an exclusive interview with PEOPLE, Pidgeon, 30, expressed her admiration for Kelly, saying, “Oh my gosh. He looked great. He always does. He’s such an amazing guy.” This conversation occurred during the Time100 Next Gala in New York City on October 29.

Pidgeon revealed she was unaware of Kelly’s achievement prior to the announcement. “No, he kept it a secret,” she said. “He knew about it since August or something, and yeah, he didn’t tell a soul.”

Paul Anthony Kelly’s role in the FX series Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr. & Carolyn Bessette, executive produced by Ryan Murphy, marked his entry into the acting world. The series highlighted the relationship between Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy and John F. Kennedy Jr., portrayed by Pidgeon and Kelly, respectively. This project aired in February and signaled Kelly’s debut acting role. Following this, Kelly appeared in American Horror Story: 13, another FX production. He is set to star in the upcoming 2027 film The Housemaid’s Secret, the sequel to The Housemaid.

During his centerfold photoshoot for PEOPLE, Kelly reflected on the impact of the series’ success. He described it as “an incredible gift” and shared, “This year has absolutely been a whirlwind of changes in both my professional and personal life. I love this job. I’ve never felt more alive and more in a place where I truly feel like I belong. So, I want this for the rest of my life.”

The series is available for streaming on FX and FX on Hulu. PEOPLE’s Sexiest Man Alive tradition began with the 2025 issue, which featured Role Model as the first-ever centerfold, while Jonathan Bailey graced the cover.

TAGS: