Melissa Batie-Smoose, a former assistant volleyball coach at San Jose State University (SJSU), has filed a new lawsuit over alleged mistreatment related to the university’s controversy involving transgender athlete Blaire Fleming and female teammate Brooke Slusser. Her initial lawsuit was dismissed last September, but Batie-Smoose is now bringing forth new allegations regarding her suspension and subsequent dismissal.
Her complaint contends that SJSU’s head volleyball coach Todd Kress ridiculed her for supporting Donald Trump and reacted adversely to her religious objections to a transgender athlete’s participation. She also claims Kress made her feel unsafe during specific interactions. Batie-Smoose repeatedly expressed to Kress that her beliefs prevented her from treating a male athlete as female, to which she claims Kress responded with hostility and criticized her political views.
Kress allegedly mocked her during practices, calling her ‘Trump-loving’ or a ‘Trump lover’ in front of players. Batie-Smoose details exclusion from meetings and reduced coaching responsibilities due to her political stance. Her relationship with Kress began years earlier at Florida State University and continued at Fairfield University before she joined SJSU in 2023.
The filing describes a confrontation over a canceled recruit visit when Kress purportedly ignored Batie-Smoose’s greeting and subsequently berated her in her office. She reported feeling unsafe during this encounter. Despite reporting the incident to human resources, Kress faced no disciplinary measures.
The complaint includes other allegations involving Kress, such as berating a player who suffered panic attacks and harsh treatment of another player for being late. It also touches on a prior accusation against Kress from a former Fairfield player, claiming assault in a hotel room in 1998.
Batie-Smoose filed a Title IX complaint on October 29, 2024, citing unequal treatment and failures to address concerns regarding transgender athlete participation and female players. Shortly afterward, the university placed her on administrative leave, prohibiting campus access and contact with student-athletes. Accusations against her included differential treatment, improper disclosure of information, and unprofessional conduct.
Batie-Smoose denies these allegations, asserting that she was treated differently than Kress and that the university used them as a pretext against her. Despite acknowledging having a drink in the presence of players, she denies purchasing or encouraging their consumption. She contests the claim of her professional misconduct, stating her responsibilities did not include a refusal to coach athletes.
Her lawsuit seeks reinstatement to her former role, compensation, and correction of adverse records from SJSU. She has since taken a head coaching position at Cisco College, but remains committed to challenging the university’s decisions.
SJSU and the California State University (CSU) system have declined to comment due to ongoing litigation. The complex legal battle includes allegations of discrimination, potential violations of Title IX, and differing interpretations of laws regarding transgender athletes and athletic eligibility rules.
The legal landscape has evolved, with changes to policies on women’s teams’ participation based on biological sex. The Supreme Court upheld these restrictions while leaving unresolved certain questions of legality in excluding transgender athletes from female teams.
The CSU argues that conduct during the seasons in question adhered to legal standards, athletic rules, and protected student privacy. Investigations found Batie-Smoose discriminated against Blaire Fleming, but she contests these findings.
Batie-Smoose remains determined to restore her reputation and address what she views as unjust treatment in a matter that spans discrimination, sports eligibility, and campus politics.
