The NFL needs to revamp its kicking game. Recent feats, like Chiefs’ Harrison Butker’s 69-yard field goal, show that today’s kickers are excelling. Yet, the kicking game feels predictable. NFL’s previous adjustments to extra points and kickoffs haven’t captivated fans. Here are four proposals to enhance the experience.
1. Introduce a Top Crossbar on Goal Posts
Transform the goalpost into a rectangle. This challenges kickers to avoid kicking too high, adding complexity and excitement to each attempt. Routine 38-yard kicks become more engaging. Many NFL kickers practice making 70-80 yard field goals. Increasing the difficulty with a top crossbar will test precision alongside distance.
2. Replace the Coin Toss and Kickoff
Initiate the game with a sprint for possession. One player from each team races from the goal line. The first to reach the ball at the 50-yard line gains initial possession at their own 20-yard line. This start emphasizes athleticism and strategy.
3. Revamp the Scoring Aftermath
After scoring, place the ball at the scoring team’s 35-yard line. They must advance 20 yards in one play to maintain possession. Failing this, the opposing team gains control. This strategy replaces the onside kick, offering varied tactical plays.
4. Eliminate Sudden Death Overtime
Adopt the college football playoff overtime rules. Both teams get possession opportunities, eliminating the impact of a strong kicker in securing early victories. The home team decides on the action in the first possession. This alternates if the score ties.
Implementing these changes will reduce predictability, enhance fun, and increase the strategic element of the game. Testing any of these changes in pre-season could offer insights on their impact.
Additional suggestions include using safer helmets and eliminating long halftime shows to keep the focus on football. An initial sprint to midfield for ball possession would be a great spectacle too.
Jason Chaffetz, a former BYU placekicker and congressman, is a contributor and podcast host for Fox News.