Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth made headlines by announcing that the execution of Nidal Hasan, scheduled for December 3, would be shown live. President Donald Trump supported the idea, considering it a strong deterrent, although a bipartisan backlash prompted a reversal of this decision.
The history of public executions is dark. In 1936, Rainey Bethea, a Black man, was hanged in Owensboro, Kentucky. Over 20,000 spectators gathered to witness the event, which took on a disturbingly celebratory atmosphere. This marked one of the last public executions in the United States. There was significant national outrage, and public executions ceased by 1938.
Trump’s proposal to livestream Hasan’s execution reignited the debate about public executions.
Death penalty discussions often focus on its role as a deterrent. However, as a former prosecutor and defense attorney for South Carolina, the author acknowledges execution does not deter crime—it merely prevents further criminal acts by the executed individual.
The author reflects on his experiences, including advocating for the death penalty in certain cases, such as Donald “Pee Wee” Gaskins. Gaskins had committed numerous murders, even on death row, indicating an extreme threat that only execution could halt. Yet, the author warns against making executions public spectacles, emphasizing that such displays have more in common with the criminal than with justice.
The proposed streaming of Hasan’s execution suggests a shift towards treating death as entertainment, a notion that Trump, with his reality TV background, appeared ready to embrace. While executions should serve justice and closure for victims, broadcasting them equates to exploiting tragedy for viewership, ultimately teaching a dangerous lesson that human life is devalued.
Dick Harpootlian, reflecting on these themes, holds that executions are a somber necessity, not a public display. His long career in law offers perspective on the complex ethical considerations involved. Although this proposal was stopped, it highlights ongoing concerns about how society views and treats capital punishment.
