Mahsa Saeidi, an investigative reporter with CBS News New York, has uncovered exclusive details in the ongoing legal case concerning an alleged gang rape at Cornell University. The case revolves around a former student who claims she was drugged and sexually assaulted in 2024 at the Chi Phi fraternity house.
The Tompkins County district attorney is reopening the investigation as new text message evidence comes to light. The initial statement from the victim, known as Jane Doe, reportedly differs from the claims in a recently filed civil lawsuit. The new evidence involves text messages between Doe and one of the accused.
Text Message Revelations
Two days after the supposed incident, text exchanges show a man apologizing for the situation, stating that he and another man were too intoxicated to intervene properly. Doe’s messages indicate her memory was also unclear, mentioning that none of the sexual activities were illegal in nature. However, she proposed avoiding excessive parties and substances in the future.
A group Snapchat conversation involving the fraternity was also obtained, offering further context.
Doe’s Attorney Responds
Thomas Giuffra, Doe’s attorney, acknowledged the text exchanges but could not verify their authenticity. He asserted that Doe was in denial and traumatized. Giuffra believes that Doe, being severely intoxicated, was cautious in her communication to gather information on the night’s events.
Giuffra stated these texts were reviewed during Cornell’s Title IX proceedings. He posits that Doe’s denial complicated her ability to express the gravity of the incident initially, yet Cornell proceeded with expelling the defendant, which he interprets as a recognition of misconduct.
University’s Impact on Doe
Giuffra underscored how Cornell had been a lifelong aspiration for Doe, who had worked tirelessly to gain admission. He disputes the district attorney’s interpretation of Doe’s original statement, maintaining it aligns with the lawsuit’s claims.
Despite the serious allegations, none of the accused have faced arrest, and the defense maintains innocence.