A federal judge has denied the Department of Justice’s request to require California election officials to segregate approximately 20,000 ballots allegedly cast by noncitizens. This decision highlights concerns over the potential threat to democracy posed by such actions. The DOJ sought a temporary restraining order against officials in California and Los Angeles County to set aside these ballots while legal proceedings continue.
In his ruling, Judge David O. Carter emphasized the dangers of undermining ongoing elections based on unproven allegations. He noted, “If the Executive can discount votes and threaten an ongoing election due to unproven allegations, our democracy is in danger.” He warned that eroded trust in democracy causes irreparable harm.
“Eroded trust in our democracy is irreparable. Once a vote is segregated, lasting harm has occurred.”
The judge found that the government had not shown a likelihood of success with its claims. He explained that the requested actions could disrupt the ongoing election, create fear among election workers and voters, and discount legitimate votes.
Carter also mentioned that the DOJ has unsuccessfully filed at least 31 federal lawsuits seeking voter rolls. He questioned both the federal government’s standing and whether federal law allows such intervention.
Reasons for Rejection
The court concluded that federal laws prohibiting noncitizen voting do not clearly supersede California’s election laws. The government could not prove that federal law overrides the state’s ballot-counting processes or mandates separating ballots based on its voter list.
Carter expressed doubts about the reliability of the government’s evidence, citing concerns about inaccuracies in citizenship databases. Past attempts to identify noncitizen voters have resulted in many false positives. The judge warned against changing election procedures mid-election, which could cause confusion and disenfranchise voters.
A significant part of the ruling referred to the “Purcell principle,” a doctrine discouraging last-minute changes to election rules due to potential voter confusion and administrative issues. Carter stated that the DOJ’s proposal would disrupt established procedures during an active election period.
Context of the Dispute
The case occurs amidst a wider debate on noncitizen voting and election integrity. Federal law prohibits noncitizens from voting in federal elections, yet disputes often revolve around accurately identifying noncitizens without wrongly flagging eligible citizens.
Carter highlighted that if the government believes unlawful voting occurred, existing criminal enforcement mechanisms are available. Instead of requiring segregation of ballots, the government can investigate individual violations where evidence exists. Presently, California election officials continue counting ballots per state procedures while the lawsuit progresses.
Details on the DOJ’s Actions
The federal government provided California officials with a list of over 20,000 names earlier this month, asking for a review within 48 hours. After the state declined the DOJ’s measures, the department sued California Secretary of State Shirley Weber and Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder Dean Logan.
According to the complaint, the U.S. Citizen and Immigration Services (USCIS) compares voter-roll data with its records to find possible noncitizen matches. “High-confidence” matches involve multiple identifiers linking voter information to USCIS records.
A Department of Homeland Security spokesperson stated that federal agencies verified identities using publicly available state records, “known aliens” lists, commercial data, and other government data to minimize false positives. High-confidence matches attempt to connect voter information with an alien number in USCIS systems.
The DOJ indicated that Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) identified over 20,000 individuals registered to vote in California as likely noncitizens. The DOJ acknowledged that manual verification does not definitively establish noncitizen status for these individuals.
