Uncategorized
October 30, 2026

Judge Considers Removing Letitia James from Cornell Rape Investigation

A Sullivan County judge reviewed arguments on Thursday about whether New York Attorney General Letitia James should be removed as the special prosecutor in a reopened investigation into an alleged gang rape at Cornell University. Judge James Farrell did not give an immediate ruling.

The hearing was prompted by a challenge from defense attorney Andrew Miltenberg. Miltenberg represents Gillio Lopes, one of the accused in the case. Lopes and six other former Chi Phi fraternity members face allegations of drugging and raping a female student at Cornell in October 2024.

New York Governor Kathy Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James held a press conference on October 2, 2026, regarding the investigation into the alleged sexual assault. (REUTERS/Jeenah Moon)

The defense argued that social media comments made by James before her appointment show bias and a presumption of guilt. James had expressed support for the victim on social media, which Miltenberg claims affects her neutrality.

Attorney General James’ office responded, stating that the claims against her are baseless. The office emphasized its commitment to an investigation driven solely by facts, evidence, and the law.

Assistant Attorney General Kaitlin Vigars, representing the state, defended the appointment of James. Vigars argued that public statements alone do not suffice for disqualification. Actual prejudice must be shown, not speculative claims of bias.

The fraternity house at the center of the allegations on the Cornell University campus, October 8, 2026. (Ryan Murphy/Getty Images)

Judge Farrell questioned the circumstances leading up to James’ appointment, exploring if prior comments might bias the investigation. He also considered the risk of inconsistent legal rulings from multiple jurisdictions.

The appointment of James by Governor Hochul bypassed the local district attorney, who chose not to pursue charges. Hochul later stated that sexual offense complaints at Cornell would now be handled by the New York State Police.

Governor Hochul emphasized the importance of a safe campus environment. She stated that survivors deserve to know their allegations will be taken seriously by trained law enforcement.

The judge is expected to issue a written ruling soon on whether James will continue as the special prosecutor or if another party will take over the investigation.

TAGS: