Italian Fiesta Pizzeria, a beloved fourth-generation business on Chicago’s South Side, continues to impress with its renowned Chicago-style thin-crust pizza. Known for their own fennel sausage, they also offer a standout secret menu item: jerk chicken pizza.
Keith Lee, a TikTok food critic, visited the Hyde Park location and sampled their half jerk chicken, half sausage pizza in late August. The pizzeria, once frequented by Barack and Michelle Obama, experienced a surge in patrons following his review.
Christine Mikulec, who co-owns the pizzeria with family members, described a bustling scene across their five locations. The business roots date back to the 1940s when her great-grandparents, Connie and Phillip DeCarlo, founded it.
The jerk chicken pizza features tender white meat fused with a unique sauce from Jerk Villa, a nearby Jamaican restaurant. Steven Harris, co-owner, shared they slow-cook their chicken with spices, enhancing flavor retention. The pizza uses jerk sauce in place of red sauce, layered with mozzarella and oregano.
The jerk chicken pizza gained popularity, selling 150 to 200 gallons of sauce in under a month. The team aims to add it to the official menu soon.
Meanwhile, their sausage pizza remains the top seller. It features their homemade sausage, crafted using a special family recipe with pork butt. This sausage, along with uncooked tomato puree sauce, makes it exceptional.
Italian Fiesta’s crust, thin yet robust, uses special flour combined with milk and butter. Dough is allowed to rest briefly before baking, producing a textured crust.
The history of Italian Fiesta is rich, beginning with the original pizzeria in 1944. The focus on family recipes and quality ingredients remains steadfast, though all locations now offer only takeout.
Some popular menu options include half-and-half pizzas with toppings like shrimp with garlic, turkey sausage, hot giardiniera, jalapeƱo, and pineapple. Slices and whole pies are available, with convenient but limited service hours.
Other offerings include the Italian beef and sausage combo sandwich and the catfish dinner. The latter pairs well with spaghetti and house-made garlic bread, making for a satisfying meal.
The pizzeria lacks in seating space, leading many to enjoy their meals in parking areas, which are often busy. The restaurant maintains a simple theme, focusing heavily on the quality of food.
Opened daily from 11 a.m., the pizzeria offers late-night hours, closing earlier on weeknights but extending into the early hours on weekends.
