Uncategorized
October 20, 2026

Instacart Settles with U.S. Workers Over Hiring Practices

Instacart will pay out millions to American workers over allegations related to its job advertisement practices for roles linked to the H-1B visa to green card pathway. Newsweek reported on these issues last year. The $5 million settlement follows a similar agreement by OpenAI in August. The Department of Justice (DOJ) highlighted that OpenAI’s job postings were difficult for U.S. workers to find, leading to positions being filled only by temporary visa holders.

The instacart agreement stems from accusations that the company only accepted paper applications for roles linked to green cards. Meanwhile, electronic applications were accepted for other positions. This created barriers for U.S. workers. The Trump administration has intensified scrutiny on the PERM process. Officials, including Vice President JD Vance, announced that Microsoft, Adobe, and other employers faced suspensions from the program due to alleged fraud.

Concerns Around the H-1B Green Card Pipeline

In August 2025, Newsweek highlighted that companies seeking green cards for foreign workers on H-1B visas might exploit program loopholes. This could prevent American workers from being hired for jobs they are qualified to fill.

The Department of Labor requires that roles filled by visa holders be advertised to demonstrate that only immigrant workers can fill them before granting a green card. Advertisements must appear in at least two major Sunday newspapers, a state workforce agency site, internally at the company, and through two other methods chosen by the company.

OpenAI and Instacart were spotlighted in the report. Instacart required applicants to mail resumes to their global mobility department. A website, Jobs.Now, challenged such practices, arguing they discriminated against Americans by making job listings less visible and appearing tailored for immigrants.

Jobs.Now claimed Instacart threatened legal action against them for publicizing job ads, citing copyright issues over the use of “Instacart.” The site argues that republishing job ads is a First Amendment right, aiming to provide Americans with application opportunities.

Instacart’s PERM Process Settlement: What to Know

The DOJ announced Tuesday that their Civil Rights Division, along with the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), had been investigating allegations that Instacart discriminated against American workers based on citizenship and national origin.

Evidence suggested that the company’s hiring practices during the PERM process favored candidates with temporary visas over U.S. workers. The mail-in application process for H-1B-linked roles created additional burdens on American workers, whose applications were delayed in review.

EEOC Chair Andrea Lucas emphasized that unlawful employment barriers harming American workers prompt decisive EEOC action. The agency is committed to holding companies accountable when denying equal opportunities to U.S. workers by preferring temporary visa holders.

Workers affected from December 2023 to February 2026 will receive compensation from a $4 million fund, the DOJ stated. The remaining $1 million will serve as civil penalties to the U.S. Instacart has also agreed to revise its PERM process, train personnel on compliance with employment laws related to citizenship and national origin, and implement monitoring measures.

An Instacart spokesperson responded that the company is committed to hiring American workers, regularly promoting roles across multiple channels to ensure qualified U.S. candidates are prioritized.

Despite asserting compliance with applicable laws, Instacart expressed relief in resolving the matter to focus on their mission.

A Broader Trend of Enforcement

Instacart is not the only employer facing scrutiny over PERM recruitment differing from regular hiring practices. OpenAI also settled with a $3.2 million agreement over similar allegations regarding paper applications and visibility issues in their recruitment channels.

Cloudera earlier agreed to a resolution involving a two-year PERM program debarment after claims that U.S. workers could not apply via a functioning email address.

The Trump administration has been particularly critical of employers’ use of the H-1B program and its green card pathway. Vance described the system as treating visa holders like “indentured servants” during discussions on Microsoft’s use.

The government has prioritized addressing fraud, though systemic changes require legislative action by Congress. Instacart sees existing PERM process rules as outdated and suggests they hinder modern recruitment practices, hinting at a need for updates.

For those concerned about the current system and its impact, the Instacart settlement is insufficient. Jobs.Now urged the Department of Labor to swiftly prevent PERM discrimination, ensuring every job is first offered to an American.

TAGS: