Maj. John Snodgrass delivered the benediction at a ceremony honoring soldiers who died in the Battle of Ben Cui in Vietnam. This event took place at the gravesite of Staff Sgt. Marvin Rex Young in Odessa, Texas.
My father, former Army Staff Sgt. Tom Frame, frequently reflects on the men who fought and died alongside him in Vietnam. Recently, he and others from his unit began traveling to Texas on Veterans Day to honor Young, one of 18 men killed in the battle.
The visits have been a means for my father to connect with fellow soldiers. A significant trip occurred over the summer, marking 50 years since Ben Cui. My dad organized a reunion for soldiers from his unit and their families, the first gathering since the battle on August 21, 1968.
It’s my duty,he said, when asked why he wanted the reunion. But he doesn’t require special occasions to remember.
He consistently thinks of them, experiencing survivor’s guilt, which affects our whole family through his post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
My father’s PTSD often manifests as anger — an irrational and fierce rage. This affects relationships and trickles down to us, his children. Over the years, he has dealt with PTSD, improving in many ways by talking with other veterans.
I joined him at the summer reunion, seeing if sharing memories with his unit might aid his healing.
On August 21, my parents and I met in Odessa for a ceremony at Rex Young’s burial site, joining other veterans and families in the chapel. At 11:10 a.m., a call to arms played, marking when the men entered battle 50 years ago. That hot, humid day, my father’s unit, part of the 5th Infantry Regiment, was on a reconnaissance mission. Of the 88 in his unit, some moved through thick brush, while others manned armored carriers armed with machine guns.
Combat photographer Sgt. Don Mousseau captured moments from the Battle of Ben Cui. Suddenly, gunshots erupted. A North Vietnamese sniper killed a man instantly and injured another. Bullets filled the air, creating chaos.
Medic Gary Young mentioned the leaves moved like pouring rain,my father recalled — bullets were hitting everywhere.
A retreat was ordered, but 18 were left behind. For my father, this has been a lingering agony.
The memorial service concluded with a prayer for those lost, as my dad repeatedly does.
Post-ceremony, veterans and families gathered for lunch at a nearby golf club. They exchanged stories over desserts like peanut butter pie and cheesecake.
Years ago, silence was the norm,my dad stated. Anger at government and public left veterans reluctant to speak, preferring to bury the past.
Now, sharing is part of recovery. I recognized old faces like Pvt. Nick Fasselin, who joined my father’s unit during Ben Cui. He later saved my father’s life in another skirmish. I embraced Pvt. Abe Cardenas, the last to see Rex Young alive. Maj. Gen. Andy Anderson also attended, defying medical guidance amidst chemotherapy treatment.
Though my father remains unable to find peace with the past, the gathering provided solace. He expressed a lasting bond with his comrades, They are my men,
he said.
Yet, some aspects are irreparable, including the disparity of survival. I’ll never reconcile with that,
he confessed, Not until I’m gone.
