A Florida woman, Caylen Deller, has been convicted of first-degree murder for killing her boyfriend, Chad Mullen, in September 2024. Deller, 32, will serve a life sentence after a jury found her guilty of the crime that occurred at her horse farm in San Mateo, Florida. Apart from the murder charge, Deller was also convicted of tampering with evidence and failing to report the death.
The prosecution argued that Deller killed Mullen and concealed his body with the help of a friend and her horse. Mullen was discovered in a shallow grave over a month after he was reported missing.
“I was extremely afraid,” Deller stated during her testimony, claiming she acted in self-defense.
Deller claimed to have shot Mullen in self-defense after he allegedly became violent during a confrontation. She accused Mullen of choking her and threatening her with a hammer when she confronted him over unproven allegations of abuse against her daughter. According to her testimony, the violence led her to use a gun she obtained following an earlier altercation with Mullen in August 2024. Deller testified that she shot him twice to protect herself.
Despite her defense, prosecutors questioned her decisions following the event, highlighting her failure to contact law enforcement or inform Mullen’s family about his death. They noted that between September 2 and September 9, 2024, Deller made 28 calls to Mullen, despite describing him as violent.
Deller admitted to the jury that she did not contact police initially, fearing they would not believe her self-defense claim. “I was more concerned about getting in trouble,” she mentioned, acknowledging it was not the best course of action.
During the closing arguments, the prosecution emphasized that contacting law enforcement should have been her immediate response. Deller’s conviction marks the conclusion of a case that has drawn significant attention due to the nature of the crime and the claims of self-defense.
