Erin Moriarty: Trysten, where are we?
Trysten Mullis: We’re at the farm that I grew up on. This is where me and my brother and sister grew up. These big white buildings here are the hog barns.
Trysten Mullis, together with his siblings Taylor and Wyatt, and their parents Todd and Amy, lived on a vast 400-acre farm in Iowa. This farm was home to soybeans, corn, and pigs. It required the entire family to manage the farm’s operations.
Erin Moriarty: And what are you feeling when you look out here?
Trysten Mullis: Just nostalgia. It’s just kind of peaceful, you know?
Everything seemed normal on a November morning in 2018. Trysten, then 13, helped his parents prepare for a shipment of baby pigs while his siblings stayed inside. Amy Mullis was cleaning lights in the hog barn, her husband Todd working on the water pipes. Trysten carried heaters to the pens.
Erin Moriarty: This is the office? The shop?
Trysten Mullis: This is the office. Yes.
Trysten showed Erin inside the barn, explaining his mother’s task of cleaning light fixtures. He noticed his mother appeared dizzy and unsteady, mentioning concerns due to a recent medical procedure she had undergone.
Trysten Mullis: She was getting down kind of slow and really grabbing onto the gate. You could see her swaying a little. We knew something was not right.
Amy agreed to rest inside, but before leaving, they asked her to retrieve a pet carrier from the red shed. It was needed to protect kittens from machinery. Trysten remembers watching her walk away through a window of the barn.
About an hour-and-a-half later, noticing the carrier wasn’t outside, Trysten went to the red shed. He found his mother on the ground with a corn rake in her back.
Trysten Mullis: I was just praying that she was still alive.
Trysten shouted for his father, and they rushed Amy to the hospital, calling 911 on the way.
911 Operator: Delaware County 911. What’s the address of your emergency?
Todd Mullis: Is she breathing?
Todd Mullis: I just grabbed her and threw her in the truck. My son’s holding her.
Amy died in the hospital. Her death deeply affected her family. Her mother Peggy, brother Jeff, and stepfather Randy struggled to comprehend the tragic event.
Initially, Trysten and Todd believed it was a horrible accident. But less than a year later, Todd faced trial for murder. The state medical examiner, Dr. Kelly Kruse, determined it was a homicide. She noted bruises on Amy’s jaw and knuckles and pointed out six puncture wounds, inconsistent with the four tines of a corn rake.
Dr. Kruse testified that the differing directions of the wounds suggested Amy was impaled multiple times. Special agent Jon Turbett suspected Todd attacked Amy after learning about her affair. Investigators discovered pertinent Google searches on Todd’s iPad, including keywords about unfaithful wives. Prosecution argued that Todd sent Trysten to find his mother after her death. Todd testified he did not commit the crime, unaware of the affair, claiming he never made such searches.
Since Trysten was the only one there, his testimony was pivotal. Initially stating he had been with his father all morning, he later admitted he left to drink water, briefly losing sight of Todd.
Prosecutor: Do you know exactly how long your dad wasn’t in your sight?
Trysten Mullis: No.
He claimed he was pressured by Amy’s stepfather, Randy, to testify as such. Trysten now believes he didn’t give the full story. He demonstrated the short time it took him to drink water, insisting it left no room for Todd to commit the murder.
Trysten Mullis: Right here is the hose that I drank out of that day.
Trysten pointed out how running the length of four football fields would leave no time for Todd to perpetrate the crime unnoticed. He confidently refuted claims against his father, adamant about Todd’s innocence.
Trysten recounted growing up abruptly with newfound responsibilities for his younger siblings as his family navigated a painful separation when Todd was imprisoned.
The defense then hired experts to argue Amy’s death was accidental. Forensic pathologist Dr. Jennifer Hammers and biomechanical engineer Dr. Valentina Ngai contested Dr. Kruse’s findings. They concluded Amy fell on the rake and, in efforts to free herself, worsened the injuries.
They demonstrated how falling back on the rake multiple times aligned with her wounds’ directions. Crucially, they noted fewer holes in Amy’s coat than wounds on her body — evidence against a violent attack.
Trysten anticipated the ruling, hoping for recognition of the evidence suggesting an accident. Though the judge denied Todd’s request for a new trial, citing sufficient representation, the family remains steadfast in pursuing justice, determined to appeal the verdict.
