The film You Can See Everything, directed by Lance Oppenheim and Nathan Fielder, presents a poignant observation of current societal dynamics. This documentary focuses on the infamous Theranos scandal and the subsequent challenges faced by Elizabeth Holmes, a prominent figure in business fraud.
Central to the film is the exploration of how today’s culture, marked by the so-called ‘grift economy’, affects our lives. In a time of modern media and divided digital spaces, the movie questions the concept of truth. You Can See Everything delves into the ethos of ‘fake it until you make it’, which is prevalent in startup culture. Elizabeth Holmes epitomizes this mindset by emulating Steve Jobs, down to the iconic black turtleneck, and falsely promising advancements in blood testing technology.
The film takes a step back from retelling the intricate details of Theranos, already documented through various media. Instead, it hinges on a 2023 statement Holmes made to The New York Times, which highlights potential dishonesty or misunderstanding. Nathan Fielder uses his discerning eye and skeptical demeanor to probe this theme further, adding depth to the narrative.
The directors choose to focus on a short recording period, during which Holmes and her partner, Billy Evans, may have attempted to construct a preferred image leading up to Holmes’ prison sentence. This aligns with corporate strategies of narrative control, termed ‘docu-washing’ in the film.
The narrative is filled with uncertainty. It raises questions about Elizabeth Holmes. Is she a naïve individual impacted by past trauma and manipulation? Billy Evans’ motives are also scrutinized. Is he genuinely supportive, or playing a role to gain sympathy or resources?
In its later stages, the film critiques media portrayals like The Dropout, which shape public perception of Holmes. These creative adaptations, while not malpractice, might still misrepresent the truth, adding another layer to the discussion.
The documentary extends its critique to include the filmmakers themselves, questioning the role of the outrage machine in grift economy narratives. The audience is reminded that visibility does not always equate to understanding, making the film a critical exploration of truth and narrative.
