Detective Susan Logothetti has spent years investigating cold cases at the Everett Police Department near Seattle. One case from 1984 captivated her: the murder of Judy Weaver, a bar manager. Judy was known for her strong personality and could handle difficult patrons. Her daughter, Cathy Myers, revealed Judy’s tough approach to dealing with unruly bar attendees.
On June 1, 1984, Judy Weaver celebrated the sale of her bar with fiancé Bill Richards. Too inebriated to drive, she decided to walk home alone. Judy was later found dead, her apartment set on fire to destroy evidence. Bill Richards was a primary suspect, but there was insufficient evidence to charge him.
In January 2023, advancements in DNA technology reopened the case. Contrary to expectations, the DNA did not match Richards but pointed to Mitchell Allen Gaff, a registered sex offender with a violent history. Detective Logothetti’s research into Gaff’s past revealed his history of violent sexual assaults, starting with officer Jackie Brown in 1979. Brown survived an attack by Gaff, who was convicted but served minimal time.
Logothetti discovered that Gaff was still on probation when Judy Weaver was murdered. Gaff continued his violent spree, attacking two teenage sisters, Angela and Myra, in August 1984. The sisters survived and identified Gaff as their attacker, leading to his conviction for aggravated rape. He was sentenced to ten years but continued to be detained post-release due to the danger he posed.
In 2024, Logothetti devised a plan to collect fresh DNA from Gaff using a chewing gum ruse. The gum sample confirmed Gaff’s involvement in Weaver’s murder. Gaff, now known as Sam Wise Price, was arrested and confessed to multiple crimes.
While preparing for trial, Logothetti received a call about another cold case: the 1980 murder of Susan Vesey. Ken Vesey, Susan’s husband, had lived under suspicion. Detective Logothetti connected Gaff to Susan Vesey’s murder using the DNA evidence from her investigation.
Gaff faced charges for both murders. As the trial neared, Gaff pleaded guilty, avoiding trial but ensuring decades behind bars. He addressed the court, claiming he had changed, but victims and families doubted his remorse. Judge Edirin Okoloko sentenced him to 50 years, concluding a decades-long pursuit for justice.
Many affected by Gaff’s crimes can now begin to heal, knowing he will not harm again. Detective Logothetti personally placed handcuffs on Gaff, symbolizing closure for his victims. This case not only brought justice but also highlighted the impact of dedication and technological advancements in solving cold cases.
