Democrats are poised to take control of both chambers of Congress. In Alaska, the Senate race remains extremely competitive and could influence the Democrats’ majority size. As of 9:24 p.m. Alaska time, Democrat Mary Peltola led Republican Senator Dan Sullivan by a slight margin of 298 votes. Peltola held 48.3 percent (79,017 votes), while Sullivan had 48.1 percent (78,719 votes), based on unofficial results from the Alaska Division of Elections. Republican Gerald L. Heikes acquired 2 percent, and independent Daniel J. Sullivan had 1.6 percent, with 211 of 403 precincts reporting.
Media outlets such as CNN, CBS News, ABC News, and Decision Desk HQ have projected Democratic control of the Senate. Previously, Alaska’s race seemed pivotal for deciding the majority, but it now mainly influences the margin.
Why Does the Alaska Senate Race Still Hold Significance?
The size of the Senate majority influences legislative actions, and Alaska’s seat remains uncertain. A victory by Peltola would place her as the 55th or 56th Democratic senator. Conversely, a win by Sullivan would narrow the margin, offering Republicans a stronger foundation for future elections.
Before the election, Forrest Nabors from the University of Alaska Anchorage foresaw the possibility of Democrats gaining a Senate majority while Sullivan retains his seat.
Implications of a Mary Peltola Victory for Democrats
Should Mary Peltola win, she would claim the first Democratic Senate seat from Alaska since 2014, when Mark Begich lost to Sullivan. Peltola, a former U.S. representative, would provide Democrats with a strategic position in a state Trump has previously won in all three presidential campaigns.
Peltola’s potential win might revive a legal battle. The Justice Department filed a lawsuit arguing if Peltola triumphs with fewer votes than the second Daniel Sullivan received, those votes might have altered the result. A judge previously dismissed this suit, though the department intends to appeal. Currently, her lead is 298 votes, while the second Sullivan has 2,693 votes.
What a Dan Sullivan Victory Means for Republicans
A win by Dan Sullivan would preserve a Republican-held seat since 2015, limiting the Democratic majority. It would also likely render the federal lawsuit irrelevant, as the Justice Department’s concerns centered on a potential Sullivan loss.
Timing for Declaring the Alaska Senate Race Result
The outcome might not be known for days or possibly weeks. Burke Croft, a consultant, informed Alaska Public Media that election night results usually represent about 70 percent of the total vote. Around 131 of the state’s over 400 precincts conduct hand counts. Additionally, absentee ballots sent abroad can be received up to 15 days post-election day.
Historically, significant shifts have occurred in election results post-election night. The 2008 and 2010 Senate races each took nearly two weeks to finalize. Registered Democrats voted early at higher rates than Republicans, with some advance votes counted after election day as reported by the Alaska Beacon. Consequently, initial results may lean Republican compared to final outcomes.
Alaska plans updates on November 10, November 13, and November 18. If no candidate surpasses 50 percent, ranked choice votes are tallied on November 18, eliminating the candidate with the fewest votes and distributing them to the next choice. The 6,000 votes from Heikes and the second Sullivan remain crucial. State officials aim to certify results by November 25.
The Second Dan Sullivan on the Ballot: Current Situation
Daniel J. Sullivan, a retired schoolteacher residing in Petersburg since 1980, runs as an independent alongside the incumbent senator Dan S. Sullivan. Initially disqualified by the state elections director for potentially causing confusion, two state courts reinstated him on the ballot.
The New York Times noted Democratic operatives with links to Peltola’s campaign recruited him, though the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee denied involvement. Peltola’s campaign stated, “The Alaskans for Mary campaign has no involvement with either Sullivan campaign.” Daniel J. Sullivan dismissed suggestions that he acts as a decoy.
In dismissing the Justice Department’s case, U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason noted that disregarding any ballots ranking him would violate Alaskans’ right to a secret ballot. In ranked-choice scenarios, ballots ranking him first with the senator second move to the senator. Ballots listing him exclusively remain uncounted further.
Poll Insights: Dan Sullivan vs. Mary Peltola
A New York Times/Siena poll conducted from October 23-30 placed Peltola at 48 percent and Sullivan at 46 percent, showing an even contest given the margin of error. Russell Luke from the University of Alaska Fairbanks shared with Newsweek that sources consistently classified the race as a toss-up.
