A federal appeals court examined the Trump administration’s request for California to set aside thousands of mail-in ballots. The Justice Department suspects these ballots relate to noncitizens before the midterm elections. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit questioned both legal and jurisdictional issues during a hearing. Attorneys for the Trump administration and California argued their positions for nearly two hours. Fox News’ Matt Finn provided the coverage.
The federal government urged the court for an immediate ruling. It argued that hundreds of thousands of California ballots could be counted daily while the dispute remains unresolved. This hearing follows the Trump administration’s emergency request concerning approximately 20,000 suspicious mail-in ballots.
“It seems to me that you want us to issue an injunction that is entirely inconsistent with the law that the California legislature has adopted,” remarked Circuit Judge Mark Bennett.
The Department of Justice wants ballots associated with individuals on its list set aside while eligibility is reviewed, rather than processed normally. Circuit Judge Mark Bennett, a Trump appointee, questioned compatibility with the Elections Clause. This clause grants state legislatures authority over election details, under congressional regulation.
The panel also examined if the Ninth Circuit has jurisdiction to intervene now. Judge Gabriel Sanchez noted the district court’s pending decision on the DOJ’s request. A hearing with Judge David Carter was scheduled for the following Tuesday.
Judge Patrick Bumatay focused on voting by noncitizens and California’s methods for handling such concerns. The Justice Department sought emergency relief from the appeals court due to a missed deadline by Judge Carter.
California contends the Ninth Circuit should wait for the lower court’s ruling. The suit was filed two weeks after California started voting by mail for the midterms.
A three-judge panel questioned the Trump administration’s emergency request to set aside thousands of California mail ballots ahead of the midterm elections.
The Trump administration accused California of mishandling voter rolls. This claim was disputed by California, emphasizing its safeguards against noncitizen voting. Los Angeles County has noted discrepancies in the federal government’s list. Some listed were born in the United States or were not registered to vote.
California argued that the federal government’s approach would disrupt Constitutional principles. States control election administration unless Congress legislates otherwise. Over 3 million votes have been cast statewide, with more than 500,000 from Los Angeles County.
The Justice Department highlighted urgency, asserting every day without a decision risks further ballot processing before citizenship issues are resolved. The panel, led by Bennett, aims to expedite the ruling.
