A judge has ruled that a former Cornell student, who sued Chi Phi fraternity members over rape allegations, can continue using the pseudonym “Jane Doe.” New York Supreme Court Justice Phaedra Perry-Bond stated that revealing Doe’s identity could lead to retribution, social and career difficulties, and family shame. Doe expressed concern that being identified might endanger her family and noted she has suffered from anxiety, depression, and insomnia.
The defendants did not oppose Doe’s request to use a pseudonym. The ruling was made considering the case’s notoriety and potential threats to those involved. Justice Perry-Bond emphasized that harassment or threats could be federal crimes. She chose not to seal court documents or close proceedings, ensuring public access.
Doe will remain anonymous, while defendants will be named in legal filings. Justice Perry-Bond suggested protecting sensitive information such as addresses and contact details for defendants. Parties in the case can propose protective agreements.
Doe filed her lawsuit in September, alleging drugging and rape by seven former fraternity members on October 19, 2024. She also named the fraternity, university, and a bar visited that night. Defendants deny wrongdoing, with some claiming consensual activity.
The fraternity was suspended on November 8, 2024, when Doe reported the assault. Local prosecutor Matthew Van Houten initially declined criminal charges, referencing Doe’s sworn statement describing drug use and sexual conduct as voluntary. CBS New York later obtained interviews where Doe claimed rape.
Van Houten reopened the investigation due to discrepancies between Doe’s lawsuit and her statement. New York Gov. Kathy Hochul removed Van Houten, appointing state Attorney General Letitia James as special prosecutor. James’ appointment has faced criticism for alleged bias based on her social media activity.
Attorney General James filed a court response asserting her position and the governor’s authority. A motion to disqualify James from grand jury proceedings remains pending, associated with claims of prejudicing the jury.
