As the LSU Tigers gear up for their season opener against the Clemson Tigers, focus extends beyond just the game. The college football world is watching closely to see if players like tight end Dae’Quan Wright and former Notre Dame defensive end Junior Tuihalamaka can play for LSU. They caused controversy by reuniting with Lane Kiffin at the NCAA level after being released from the Cleveland Browns following a training camp stint.
Amid this anticipation, a debate surrounds a growing trend: former NFL rookies and athletes attempting to return to college for a fifth year of eligibility. The SEC and major conferences resist new guidelines, while injunctions and temporary restraining orders from judges have led to court proceedings. This has strained relations among the NCAA, conferences, and schools.
Financial Incentives and NCAA Rules
Ben McDonald, a former LSU Tigers star and the first overall pick of the 1989 MLB Draft, voiced his opinion on this matter on “America Reports.” McDonald stated, “Once you play your four years, it’s time to move on.” Yet, he acknowledges the financial lure of NIL money as a reason for players wanting to return to college sports.
If you can’t make it in professional sports, a fifth year in college might be appealing for financial gain.
One of the NFL’s renowned agents, Drew Rosenhaus, supports players returning under the NCAA’s “5-for-5” rule, enabling athletes to play five years. He highlights that financially, players earn more in college than on NFL practice squads.
Development Advantage
Nebraska coach Matt Rhule sees a developmental advantage in players like Wright, who have faced professionals in training camps. Rhule remarked that players return “twice as good,” emphasizing how crucial this experience is for coaching.
As for LSU coach Lane Kiffin, he sees great potential in welcoming experienced players back. “If I’m a college coach and have the chance to snag a player with four years plus NFL exposure, why wouldn’t I?” he remarked.
Debate Among Coaches
While Kiffin is open to the return of former pros, others in the SEC, such as Texas’ Steve Sarkisian, are against it. Sarkisian expressed to ESPN that it morally conflicts with players who have been committed for months.
The situation involves not only the decision of individual schools but also legal matters. A judge will soon decide whether to uphold or reverse a restraining order affecting SEC policies. This decision comes right before LSU’s roster deadline and their game against Clemson.