November 5, 2026

Alaska’s Electoral Challenges and Surprises

For months, Alaska’s ballot was at the center of a contentious battle over who deserved a spot on it. Dan J. Sullivan, a retired teacher from Petersburg, filed to contest against Senator Dan S. Sullivan. This sparked a legal and political struggle as concerns arose about voter confusion due to the similarity of their names. Ultimately, the Alaska Supreme Court allowed Dan J. Sullivan to remain on the ballot.

The controversy didn’t end there. A report by The New York Times linked Dan J. Sullivan’s candidacy to a Democratic operative. The campaign of Mary Peltola, a Democrat challenging Senator Sullivan, denied any involvement. Meanwhile, former President Donald Trump expressed concerns that voters would be misled by the similar names.

As of the latest count, Dan J. Sullivan trailed significantly with only 1.7 percent of the votes. A more unexpected outcome emerged in Alaska’s U.S. House race; Eric Hafner, a Democrat serving a 20-year federal sentence and not residing in Alaska, garnered 7.3 percent of the vote. This far exceeded Dan J. Sullivan’s total. Even though Hafner’s own party had urged voters not to support him, preferring independent Bill Hill, his participation altered the voting dynamics.

Examining Hafner’s vote size reveals its significance. Republican Representative Nick Begich led Hill by 9 points, with a margin of 49.6 percent to 40.4 percent. If Hafner’s votes were combined with Hill’s, the gap would narrow to under 2 points, affecting about 4,100 votes out of over 213,000. This does not indicate where Hafner’s supporters might have redirected their votes, but it illustrates his substantial influence in the election where Democrats supported Hill.

Voting Mechanics in Alaska

The scrutiny centered on Dan J. Sullivan, yet Hafner accumulated more votes. Under Alaska’s voting rules, those votes might remain locked in first-choice preferences. Alaska’s top-four primary winners progress to a ranked-choice general election. If a candidate doesn’t secure a majority of first-choice votes, the last-place candidate is removed, and their ballots are allocated based on voters’ next preferences. This continues round by round until a candidate surpasses 50 percent.

This system aims to counter the spoiler effect, allowing votes for lesser-known candidates to influence stronger contenders. However, if a candidate isn’t eliminated, their voters’ preferences may not advance, as the count stops when a candidate reaches 50 percent.

The House Race and Hafner’s Impact

In the House race, involving 400 of 403 precincts according to the Alaska Division of Elections, Begich clinched a 9-point victory. Despite Hill being the preferred left candidate, Hafner’s 15,550 votes are significant. Begich misses the majority by less than 1,100 votes. McDermott’s 5,800 votes will be redistributed first. If they propel Begich above 50 percent, Hafner’s ballots remain unexamined.

Senate Dynamics: Narrow Margins

For the Senate, the unofficial count shows a tight competition with Peltola leading by 637 votes without a majority. Dan J. Sullivan’s 3,600 votes and those from Gerald Heikes will be redistributed. Despite intense legal contention involving Dan J. Sullivan, he attracted fewer votes than Heikes. Since Heikes ran as a Republican, his votes could potentially favor Sullivan. The outcome hinges on how these voters ranked candidates, with answers expected on November 18.

Anticipated Election Results

The provisional results offer a Republican-biased snapshot, as about 70 percent of votes are counted on election night. According to a consultant’s statement to Alaska Public Media, late shifts of around 4 points are not uncommon. Early ballots from after October 29 weren’t part of the initial count, with registered Democrats voting early in higher numbers. This trend suggests a more Republican-leaning election night result compared to final tallies.

In a past example from 2024, the repeal measure for ranked-choice voting led initially but was defeated by 743 votes after counting later ballots.

Debate Over Ranked-Choice Voting

This election also featured a vote on whether to scrap ranked-choice voting, attempted for the second time in two years. The Alaska Republican Party strongly endorsed the repeal through Ballot Measure 2. Despite their efforts, which included support from Trump, early counts showed the measure trailing.

Ironically, the same system Republicans want to eliminate could end up favoring them, potentially sealing Begich’s win while Sullivan benefits from second-choice votes against Peltola.

Upcoming Updates

Alaska’s electoral focus on a shared surname will likely result in Dan J. Sullivan’s early elimination, redistributing his ballots. Meanwhile, Hafner’s sizeable share may not extend beyond initial preferences.

The state’s vote count updates on November 10 and November 13, with ranked-choice tabulations on November 18. Certification is anticipated by November 25, although all numbers are unofficial and subject to change.

TAGS: