Advocates for racial reparations have recently celebrated a legislative success in California with the signing of Assembly Bill 2599, referred to as the Truth in Disclosure Act, by Governor Gavin Newsom. Despite this achievement in corporate transparency, key figures emphasize the importance of direct cash compensation.
Kristin Nimmers, the policy and campaign manager for the California Black Power Network (CBPN) and the Alliance for Reparations, Reconciliation, and Truth, insists that financial reparations should move beyond a singular payment. She states, “We really focus on a harm-based approach, so whoever was harmed should be entitled to that repair.” Nimmers believes compensation should address slavery, unpaid labor, and the unfulfilled promise of 40 acres and a mule, exclusively benefitting descendants of enslaved people.
“Compensation for slavery, unpaid labor, for the 40 acres and a mule that were promised after the end of slavery – that should go to folks who have lineage and are descendants of people who were enslaved because that is the harm that is being repaired.” – Kristin Nimmers
The California Black Power Network argues that racial inequities have persisted far beyond chattel slavery. Nimmers explains that Black Americans have faced wage denial, property denial, and lack of access to capital and education. She emphasizes that these issues span hundreds of years, so a single check cannot repair the communities affected.
Assembly Bill 2599 requires corporations in California, with over $100 million in gross revenue, to search historical records and disclose ties to chattel slavery. Lawmakers and advocates aim to use the bill to fuel broader recommendations from the California Reparations Task Force. The task force’s influential 1,100-page final report was informed by public testimony gathered with the help of the California Black Power Network, acting as a state community anchor.
Despite these efforts, direct cash payouts face significant challenges. Although Governor Newsom signed AB 2599, he remains cautious about direct financial restitution, often vetoing costly payout proposals. Newsom’s administration has not publicly responded to requests for comment on CBPN’s stance regarding direct compensation.
Additionally, progressive coalitions encounter internal disagreement. The U.S. Freedmen Project, composed of self-identified “Foundational Black Americans,” advocates for a narrower eligibility rooted in the direct descent from enslaved individuals in the U.S. They argue against recent immigrants and Black Americans who do not meet their ancestry criteria being included in government reparations programs.
Contrarily, Nimmers supports a broader harm-based approach. She argues that systemic discrimination impacted many Black residents, including those affected by segregated schools and redlining pre-Civil Rights Act. Nimmers states, “If you are a Black person—maybe a Black immigrant who came here in the 1950s before the Civil Rights Act was passed—then you also experienced segregated schools.” She believes such individuals should be included in reparations efforts.
“Reparations is not a handout. It is about acknowledging, addressing, and repairing harm.” – Kristin Nimmers
Even as state-level cash proposals remain stalled, local efforts have made progress. For instance, in Evanston, Illinois, the Reparations Committee approved housing grants of $25,000 for 44 Black residents as part of addressing historical redlining and zoning discrimination.
California advocates continue to pursue a comprehensive reparations plan, aiming for both financial compensation and systemic policy reform. Nimmers affirms, “What is the repair for that harm, and who fits within the group that was harmed? It’s necessary because we are owed compensation for unpaid labor and historical harms.”
