November 20, 2026

A Unique Divorce Journey

Holly Zeilenga, a piano teacher-turned-content creator from Madison, Wisconsin, shared her journey of love and divorce with Business Insider. The story reflects her experience with former husband James and their non-traditional path following a divorce.

Meeting Online

Holly met James online in August 2020 during the pandemic. As a single mom by choice, already caring for her second child, she connected with James while playing the online game “Guns of Glory.” Their friendship grew quickly, and by October, James visited Holly and her children, who took to him warmly. A strong bond formed, and by April, James proposed. They married in December 2021 at a small chapel.

Family Life and Challenges

The newly blended family enjoyed shared activities, and Holly’s children affectionately called James “Dad.” The couple wished for a child together, but faced infertility issues. Holly endured about 14 procedures, including IVF, which culminated in a miscarriage and a tragic loss in the second trimester of another pregnancy. Surrogacy became their last resort, and they committed to the $100,000 fee, working tirelessly, including crowdfunding.

A Turning Point

After much effort, their relationship faced a turning point. Holly and James discussed their diverging goals and chose to part ways, filing for divorce in June. Their friendship eased the transition back to a platonic relationship. Although James moved out in July, he continued to visit the kids regularly. The divorce finalized on November 2 with no complications.

Celebrating a New Beginning

The duo marked the end at the courthouse together, showing mutual respect. Afterward, they celebrated with a meal at Olive Garden, reminiscent of past visits during their marriage. They enjoyed the outing, which concluded at a JCPenney and a Hobby Lobby, where Holly shared the experience on her social media, resonating with many who viewed the clip.

James’s continued presence comforts the children, and both Holly and James remain supportive of each other’s potential new relationships. Holly plans to pursue surrogacy using her eggs and a donor’s sperm, a decision James supports fully.

For those finding themselves in similar situations, Holly advocates for celebrating the end of a marriage when possible, as it provides closure and welcomes the next chapter of life.

TAGS: