The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court has agreed to review an appeal by Lindsay Clancy’s defense team. This move highlights the ‘exceptional circumstances’ surrounding the case.
Lindsay Clancy is charged with the murder of her three children in January 2023: Cora, age 5; Dawson, age 3; and 8-month-old Callan. Her first trial ended in a mistrial in September 2026 when the jury was split 11-1, apparently leaning towards a verdict of not guilty due to lack of criminal responsibility.
Clancy’s defense attorneys, Kevin Reddington and Martin Weinberg, sought case dismissal citing double jeopardy violations following the mistrial. They argued that the lone juror acknowledged reasonable doubt but ignored legal instructions. The court received a note from the jury foreperson stating the holdout juror was not adhering to guidelines.
In response, Judge William Sullivan ruled against the motion to dismiss in a 17-page order on November 9, 2026. Sullivan stated that the note did not suggest the juror’s inability to deliberate or follow the law. He noted any questioning of the juror would be ‘impermissibly coercive.’ Sullivan determined a retrial was warranted due to the jury deadlock.
Sullivan wrote, ‘Because the Court concludes that there was a manifest necessity for a mistrial based on the jury’s deadlock, a retrial on the murder indictments does not violate Clancy’s right not to be placed in double jeopardy.’
Despite the lower court’s decision, the state’s highest court will hear Clancy’s bid to dismiss her murder charges in January 2027. This precedes her scheduled retrial starting March 29, 2027.
A court document from November 19, obtained by PEOPLE, confirms the scheduled oral argument. Supreme Judicial Court Justice Elizabeth N. Dewar clarified that the Court’s intervention occurs only in ‘the most exceptional circumstances’ lacking alternative remedies.
Clancy’s defense must submit an appeal brief by December 3, 2026, with prosecutors responding by December 17, 2026. She remains in custody at Tewksbury Hospital as proceedings continue.
