A retired police sergeant with nearly 30 years of experience has expressed concerns about safety in New York City. Sgt. Betsy Brantner Smith, representing the National Police Association, spoke with Fox News Digital. She highlighted potential risks following Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s decision to reorganize the NYPD.
Mamdani plans to disband the Strategic Response Group (SRG), a specialized 500-officer unit. The SRG focuses on counterterrorism, event security, and protest management. This move aims to redefine the NYPD’s approach to demonstrations and counterterrorism efforts.
Concerns from Law Enforcement
Smith warned that dismantling the unit could jeopardize response capabilities. She noted that the SRG consists of officers with shared training and specialized skills. These skills are essential for handling emergencies, including active shooter scenarios.
Her comments come as New York City gears up for the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. The event typically draws large crowds, raising concerns about security gaps if the SRG is disbanded.
First and foremost, I’m concerned that any intelligence may be lost or may be ignored for a large scale event like this,
Smith stated.
The NYPD has responded with reassurances. Assistant Commissioner Brad Weeks indicated the restructuring would not affect the parade’s security. A new unit, the First Amendment Support Team, will begin operations in 2027. This transition includes transferring counterterrorism efforts to the Counterterrorism Bureau.
Changes in Protest Response
Mayor Mamdani defends these changes as part of his promise to differentiate counterterrorism from protest response. He emphasized that protest management should not equate to handling terrorism threats.
The overhaul includes imposing restrictions on police tactics during protests, such as banning long guns and tear gas. Pepper spray will no longer be a general crowd-management tool. The new Patrol Support Division will train for specific scenarios while retaining arrest powers.
I’ve long said that counterterrorism and protest response are fundamentally different responsibilities and that New Yorkers exercising their constitutional right to protest should not be met with the same police response as a terrorism threat,
Mamdani stated.
Public Opinion and Reactions
A Change.org petition from the National Police Association urges Mamdani to reconsider. The petition, which shows strong public support, argues the SRG’s expertise aids public safety.
Opposition comes from both sides. Some far-left groups applauded the SRG’s dismantling, viewing it as a victory for movements critical of NYPD’s handling of protests.
NPDY Leadership’s Stance
NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch supported the restructuring, assuring the department’s readiness to face significant threats. She stressed maintaining sufficient resources for policing.
I would never support changes that diminish the NYPD’s ability to protect New Yorkers, or that put our officers in a position where they lack the resources necessary to confront a serious threat,
Tisch remarked.
Mamdani’s decision continues to ignite discussion among officials and activists, with ongoing debates on the best path forward for NYC’s law enforcement strategies.
